Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

119 Mass. 556

Chase v. Aldermen

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1876-03-01

<p>On a petition for a writ of certiorari to bring up and quash the proceedings of an inferior tribunal, an answer of the tribunal containing allegations and denials of fact, and signed by counsel, is irregular.</p> <p>It is no ground for a writ of certiorari to quash the proceedings of a tribunal, authorized to assess betterments for the laying out of a highway, that the records of the tribunal do not show that a grade line was established.</p> <p>The erection of railings or barriers, required for the safety of public travel, is not essential to the completion of a public way under the St. of 1871, c. 382, § 1; and the want thereof does not prevent the assessment of betterments under that section.</p> <p>The record of the board of city or town officers of their proceedings in the laying out or altering of a way and the assessment of betterments therefor, under the St. of 1871, c. 382, should show the amount of the expense of the laying out or altering, as well as of the assessment.</p> <p>A petition for a writ of certiorari to quash the proceedings of a tribunal of a city assessing a betterment tax on an estate for the laying out of a highway, under the St. of 1871, c. 382, alleged that the proceedings were void because it did not appear that the amount assessed was a proportional part of the expense of laying out and grading the street. The answer alleged that it sufficiently appeared by the records that the expense of laying out and grading the street was largely in excess of the amount assessed by the tribunal, and that the amount so assessed was a proportional part of said expense. The answer also alleged that, in fact, said expense was largely in excess of the amount assessed, and said amount was a proportional part of said expense. The record annexed to the petition showet an adjudication that the whole amount of benefit and advantage received by any real estate from the laying out of the street, beyond the general advantage to all real estate in the city, was $31,050, one half of which, viz.: $15,525, should be assessed upon the lots of land specially benefited, in proportion to the benefit and advantage received by each. By consent of the parties, the case was reserved for this court upon the petition and answer and a report of a single justice, which stated that the records did not show the actual expense of laying out and constructing the road, or that the amount assessed upon the lands benefited was a proportional part of said expense; but that, if it could be shown in this way, it could be proved by the books of public record of the city, and by paroi, that the actual expense of laying out and constructing the road was between $21,000 and $22,000, and that the assessment of betterments was a proportional part of about two thirds of that sum. Held, that, although the record was defective in not showing th« amount of the expense, yet that defect could be cured by an amendment of the record, and, upon the allegations in the answer, the agreement of the parties as to the effect thereof, and the facts found at the hearing, afforded no ground for a writ of certiorari to issue.</p> <p>An order of the proper tribunal of a city, laying a betterment tax under the St. of 1871, c. 382, directed the tax collector to collect said assessment, with interest at twelve per cent, per annum. Held, on a petition for a writ of certiorari, which did not assign the order to collect interest as one of the errors, that the validity of the order laying the assessment was not affected thereby.</p>

Relies on Farmington River Water Power Co. v. County Commissioners · Inhabitants of Tewksbury v. County Commissioners · Worcester & Nashua Railroad v. Railroad Commissioners

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1876-03-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 13 later decisions — most recently January 2011

13 state decisions

40187618801890190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1The answer to this petition, containing allegations and denials of matters of fact, and signed by counsel, is irregular. Tewksbury v. County Commissioners, 117 Mass. 563. Worcester & Nashua Railroad v. Railroad Commissioners, 118 Mass. 561. But by consent of the parties the case has been submitted with the same effect as if the facts stated in the report appeared by a proper return made officially by the respondents.

¶21. The objection “ because no grade line has been established ” is not well founded. The statutes do not require that such a line shall be formally established and defined upon the record of the proceedings, except so far as may be necessary to a proper specification of the manner in which the new highway or alteration shall be made. Gen. Sts. c. 43, § 13. So far as the rights *563or liabilities of abutters are affected by the grade of the street, they depend on and are determined by the grade as actually con structed.

¶32. The objection 66 that the work of laying out and grading said avenue had not been completed ” is not sustained in fact. The mere want of .railings or barriers for the protection and safety of public travel does not prevent the board from proceeding to assess the expenses. Whiting v. Mayor Aldermen of Boston, 106 Mass. 89.

¶43. The assessment, authorized by the St. of 1871, c. 382, § 1, is a tax, by which the expense of the laying out and construction of the way is apportioned as a public burden upon the lands especially benefited by the public improvement. The benefit or advantage to such lands is estimated only as a means of apportioning the tax and of providing a fixed limit of the amount to be assessed upon each estate. The fact of such benefit from the improvement furnishes a justification for the imposition of the tax upon a particular class of estates, instead of a levy in the general way of ordinary taxation. But such benefit conferred would not of itself alone warrant the exaction of money by way of compensation therefor. The estates are assessed, not for the benefit conferred, but for the cost of the public improvement. The essential point in the proceeding is the expenditure for a public service, for which taxation in some form is required.

¶5The record of the board of aldermen is defective in not showing what the amount of that expense was. But the defect may and should be cured by an amendment of that record, and, upon the allegations in the answer, the agreement of the parties as to the effect thereof and the facts found at the hearing before a single justice, affords no reason why the court, in the exercise of its discretion, should order a writ of certiorari to issue. Farmington River Water Power Co. v. County Commissioners, 112 Mass. 206. Noyes v. City Council of Springfield, 116 Mass. 87. The order of the board of aldermen, taken in connection with the facts thus alleged and admitted, shows that each estate has been assessed, in proportion to the benefit and advantage received, a share of the expense of laying out and construction, not exceeding the whole amount of that expense, nor half the amount of the benefit and advantage to all the estates.

¶6*5644. The objection that the record does not show that the mayor was present at the meeting of the board of aldermen was not insisted upon at the argument, and no objection was taken to the proceedings for want of the concurrence'of the common council. See Sts. 1852, c. 94, §§ 8, 14; 1871, c. 382, § 1; Day v. Aldermen of Springfield, 102 Mass. 310; Powers v. City Council of Springfield, 116 Mass. 84.

¶75. The order to collect twelve per cent, interest is not one of the errors assigned in the petition, and does not affect the validity of the order laying the assessment. Petition dismissed.

/119/mass/556 · .json · Public domain