Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

119 Misc. 770

In re Schweizer

New York Surrogate's Court

Decided December 15, 1922

New York Surrogate's Court · decided 1922-12-15

<p>Wills — probate — husband and wife — separation agreement — when widow cannot contest husband’s will.</p> <p>Where some months prior to his death decedent and his wife had lived separate and apart and the separation agreement between them provides that she shall not and will not at any time thereafter claim or demand any of his money, property, real or personal, which he then had in his power, custody or possession “ or which he shall or may at any time hereafter have, buy or procure, or which shall be devised or given to him, or that he may otherwise acquire, and that he shall and may enjoy and absolutely dispose of the same as if he were single and unmarried; and that she fully and in all respects releases him and his property, real and personal, from any and all claims whatsoever.” she is not a party in interest who may contest the will, under which no real estate passed, and a motion to dismiss her objections filed to the probate of the instrument will be granted.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1922-12-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 11 later decisions — most recently August 1970

11 state decisions

30192219301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Wingate, S.

¶1Application is made to dismiss the only objections filed to the petition for probate of decedent’s will. The application is based upon the assertion that the contestant, decedent’s widow, is not a person interested ” who is entitled to file objections under section 147 of the Surrogate’s Court Act. She was married to the decedent, but separated from him some months prior to his death. Thereafter they lived apart from each other, and entered into a separation agreement which is in evidence.

¶2Objections to the probate of a will may not be filed by one who would derive no financial benefit should the will be set aside. Matter of Hoyt, 55 Misc. Rep. 159; affd., 122 App. Div. 914; affd., 192 N, Y. 538.

¶3A separation agreement may by its terms release the interest of a wife in the property of her husband. See cases cited in 14 McKinney’s Consol. Laws, under Dom. Rel. Law, § 51; Tiffany Dom. Rel. (3d ed.) chap. VII. See, also, Titus v. Bassi, 182 App. Div. 387.

¶4The separation agreement in this case provides that the wife “ shall not and will not at any time hereafter claim or demand any of his [the decedent’s] money, property, real and personal, jewels, *771plate, clothing, household goods, furniture or stock in trade, which he has now in his power, custody or possession, or which he shall or may at any time hereafter have, buy or procure, or which shall be devised or given to him, or that he may otherwise acquire, and that he shall and may enjoy and absolutely dispose of the same as if he were single and unmarried; and that she fully and in all respects releases him and his property, real and personal from any and all claims whatsoever.” This agreement further contains the recital that all the covenants, stipulations, promises, agreements, and provisions in this instrument contained shall apply to, bind and be obligatory upon the heirs, executors, administrators, personal representatives, successors or assigns of the parties hereto, or either of them, whether so expressed or not.”

¶5There is no real estate passing by decedent’s will. If the will were denied probate, the release contained in the agreement referred to and executed by the wife, would prevent her from sharing in the personal property of her deceased husband. Under the authority of the Matter of Hoytcase, cited supra, the widow is, therefore, not a party in interest who may contest decedent’s will.

¶6The application to dismiss her objections is granted. Settle order on notice.

¶7Ordered accordingly.

/119/misc/770 · .json · Public domain