Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 E.H. Smith 175

52 N.E 1113

People Ex Rel. Fleming v. . Dalton

New York Court of Appeals

Decided February 28, 1899

New York Court of Appeals · decided 1899-02-28

The facts, so far as material, are stated in the opinion. It is essential to the determination of the questions here presented to ascertain the legislative intent. (Matter of Dobson, 146 N. Y. 357; Stack v. City of Brooklyn, 150 N. Y. 335; People v. Jaehne, 103 N. Y. 182; People ex rel. v. Lacombe, 99 N. Y. 43 ; Coutant v. People, 11 Wend. 511; Warner v. Beers, 23 Wend. 103; People v. Purdy, 2 Hill, 31; S. A. R. R. Co. v. G. E. R. R. Co., 3 Abb. [N. C.] 372; Blake v. Nat.

Relies on 11 E.H. Smith 90 - People Ex Rel. Leet v. . Keller

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1899-02-28

How this case has been cited

Cited by 49 later decisions — most recently May 1974 · most notably Touart v. State ex rel. Callaghan (1911), Pratt Institute v. . City of New York (1905)

49 state decisions

150189919001910192019301940195019601970decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, J.

¶1 (dissenting.) I dissent from the conclusion reached by Judge Bartlett, that the order of the Appellate Division should be reversed, upon two grounds. In the first place, chapter 186 of the Laws of 1898 did not apply to the city of Hew York ; my reasons for that statement being given in the Leet Case, (157 N. Y. 90), and again, somewhat more fully expressed, in the Terry case, decided at this term.

¶2 In the second place, the act of 1898, referred to, was prospective in its operation and did not affect the civil service rules and regulations which were adopted by the municipal civil service commissioners of the city of Hew York, on March 5th, 1898, and which were existing at the time; nor would affect them, until the expiration of three months, when they would cease, if not previously approved by the state board. Therefore, the removal of the relator on April 11th, 1898, because effected under regulations at the time not affected by the amending act of 1898, was valid. This ground is also covered by the discussion in the Leet and Terry Cases (supra).

¶3 I think that the order of the Appellate Division should be affirmed, with costs. O’Brien, J., concurs.

All concur (Parker, Gh. J., in result) with Bartlett, J., for reversal, except Gray and O’Brien, JJ., who file dissenting memorandum.

¶4 Order reversed, etc.

/12/ehsmith/175 · .json · Public domain