Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 F. Cas. 850

Hukill v. Page

U.S. Circuit Court for the Northern District of Illnois · decided 1874-08-15

Action on the ease by plaintiff [Edwin M. Hukill], holder of certain bonds of the Riverside Improvement Company, secured by deed of trust to the defendants [Benjamin V. Page and others], the declaration alleging that the plaintiff purchased the bonds relying upon the security of the trust deed, but that the defendants wrongfully executed and delivered to the said company a release of said trust deed, which was duly ■filed for record, whereby plaintiff’s bonds became of…

Decided 1874-08-15

BLODGETT, District Judge.

¶1Inasmuch as no fraud was charged, but negligence only is alleged in the declaration, the remedy should be by a bill of chancery. It is possible that an action on the case might lie against the trustees if fraud were alleged, but as plaintiff simply alleged negligence the only remedy is in equity. The •demurrer will be sustained and leave given to amend, if the plaintiff thinks he- can make a good declaration.

/12/fcas/850 · .json · Public domain