Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 How. Pr. 550

People v. Orser

New York Supreme Court

Decided December 20, 1855

New York Supreme Court · decided 1855-12-20

<p>Where a court of competent jurisdiction decides a jurisdictional question, (a commitment for contempt of court,) a justice of this court, at chambers, has . no right to review such decision collaterally.</p>

Decided 1855-12-20

Dean, Justice.

¶1The prisoner, John B. Overton, is imprisoned by virtue of a commitment by the court of common pleas of New-York, for an alleged contempt. The cause of the commitment is plainly charged, and set out in the commitment.

¶2The proof taken before me shows that the question on which the want of jurisdiction in the court of common pleas is charged, was raised in that court, and decided at general term.

¶3It will not do for an officer acting at chambers, collaterally, to review the decisions of courts of competent jurisdiction.

¶4The prisoner must be remanded.

/12/howpr/550 · .json · Public domain