Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 I. & N. Dec. 399

ANDERSON

Board of Immigration Appeals

Decided July 1, 1967

Board of Immigration Appeals · decided 1967-07-01

Decided 1967-07-01

                                                       Interim Decision #1775




                             MAI Lac or ANDERSON
                       In Section 212(h) Proceedings
                                    A-13243261
          Decided by Regional Convraiosioner March 17, 1967
Motion to reconsider a section 212(h) application by a native and citizen of
  Panama in the United States for a waiver of the criminal ground of excludability is denied since his application may be considered only in conjunction
  with an application for adjustment of status under section 245, Immigration
  and Nationality Act, as amended (8 CPR 245.1 (f) ) and his section 245 application, properly adjudicated prior to December 1, 1965, does not fall within the
  "savings clause" of section 8 of the Act of November 2, 1966, since on December
  1, 1965 his ineligibility for such relief was not solely because of his birth in the
  Western Hemisphere but also because of the criminal ground of inadmissibility.
IN BEHALF OF APPLICANT: Ira Gollobin, Esquire
                              1441 Broadway
                               New York, New York 10018

   The applicant is a 45-year-old native and citizen of Panama. On
July 19, 1963 he filed an application for adjustment of status under section 245 of the Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended. He
stated therein that he had never been charged with any violation of law.
 It developed that he had in fact been convicted in Balboa, Canal Zone
 on November 8, 1943 of four offenses of petit larceny. He was ineligible
for an immigrant visa and was inadmissible to the United States because of such convictions under section 212(a) (9) of the Immigration
 and Nationality Act. He was therefore statutorily ineligible for the
requested adjustment of status which was originally denied by the District Director on November 21, 1983.
    On January 10, 1964 counsel filed an application on Form 1-601 for
a waiver of excludability under section 212 (g), redesignated by P.L.
89-236 effective December 1, 1965 as section 212(h), in conjunction
with a motion for reconsideration of the section 245 application for
adjustment. The waiver application was based on a claim of extreme
hardship to his resident alien son, Robert, and a daughter, Gloria, by
his first marriage. The applicant had divorced his first wife on February 16) 1956. He was again married on July 14, 1956 in Mexico City.
                                       399
Interim Decision #1775
Mexico to Urania Garcia de Anderson, a citizen of Panama, and had
one son Juan Javier Anderson, born in Panama City on March 1, 1960
of his second marriage. His wife and son, Juan Javier Anderson were
still residing in Panama. The application for the waiver was denied
as the evidence did not establish the requisite extreme hardship to the
members of his immediate family in the United States. That decision
of the District Director, dated August 10, 1965, also necessarily denied
the motion for reconsideration of the application for adjustment of
status. Our order of October 27, 1965 dismissed the appeal from the
denial of the waiver application.
   Counsel now moves for reconsideration of the application for the
waiver of excludability only. He states the wife, Urania Garcia de
Anderson, was admitted to the United States for permanent residence
on May 28, 1966 and the child, Juan Javier Anderson, on January 29,
1967, Counsel asserts the applicant earns $150 a week, supports his
wife and child, and that the wife is taking her Masters Degree in
Education at Columbia University. No evidence has been submitted
in support of the motion.
  By published regulations (8 CFR 245.1(f)), an application for a
waiver of excludability under section 212(h) of the Act may be made
in behalf of an alien in the United States only in conjunction with an
application for adjustment of status. We will review both applications
here.
  Subsection (c) of section 245 of the Immigration and Nationality
Act was amended by section 13 (b) of the Act of October 3, 1965 (P.L.
R9-236) to read:
The provisions of this section shall not be applicable to any alien who is a native
of any country of the Western Hemisphere or of any adjacent island named in
section 101(b) (5). (Emphasis supplied.)
The emphasized phrase replaced the phrase "of any cotuttry contiguous to the United States". This change was effective December 1,
1965.
   Section 3 of the Act of November 2, 1966 added to section 13 of the
Act of October 3, 1965:
(C) Nothing contained in subsection (b) of this section shall be construed to
affect the validity of any application for adjustment under section 545 filed with
the Attorney General prior to December 1, 1965, which would have been valid
on that date; but as to all such applications the statutes or parts of statutes
repealed or amended by this Act are, unless otherwise specifically provided
therein, continued in force and effect.
  The application for adjustment of status was properly adjudicated
when before us prior to December 1, 1965. On December 1, 1965, our
applicant's ineligibility for such adjustment was not solely because of


                                          400
                                            Interim Decision #1775
his birth in the Western Hemisphere. He was also ineligible because of
inadmissibility on the criminal ground and did not then qualify for a
waiver thereof. His application for adjustment of status is not within
the "savings clause" of the Act of November 2, 1966. We may not consider the application for a waiver of excludability independently. The
motion will therefore be denied.
  It is ordered that the motion to reopen and reconsider be denied.




                                401

/12/indec/399 · .json · Public domain