Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 I. & N. Dec. 772

SMITH

Board of Immigration Appeals

Decided July 1, 1968

Board of Immigration Appeals · decided 1968-07-01

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently March 1979

1 federal appellate ·

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1968-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Interim Decision #1875




                               MAT= OF Sion(

                        In Visa Petition Proceedings

                                   A-17583656

                Decided by District Director May 17, 1968

Sixth preference classification as a secretary is accorded the beneficiary of a visa
  petition filed by an agency which furnishes secretarial, stenographic and other
  office personnel services to client firms on a temporary basis, since the petition.
  ing agency, which will pay beneficiary directly and has guaranteed her full-time permanent employment for 52 weeks a year with fringe benefits, is the
  actual employer of the beneficiary and the employment offer is not of a seasonal or temporary nature.


   The petitioner is a well-established company which operates two
distinct divisions in New York City and in other cities of the United
States and the world. One division operates as an employment service
in the traditional sense, accepting job offers from employers and making referrals of applicants to those jobs. If the applicant is hired, he
becomes the actual employee of the company to -whom the referral was
made. The other division of the company operates as an agency which
furnishes secretarial, stenographic, and other office personnel to client
firms which desire the services of such personnel on a full-time but
temporary basis. Personnel utilized by this division, however, are considered by the petitioner to be its employees. The petitioner desires
to employ the beneficiary as a secretary in this division of the company.
In order to establish the beneficiary's eligibility for sixth preference
classification the offer of employment must not be "of a temporary or
seasonal" nature within the meaning of section 203 (a) (6) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended, and the petitioner must
qualify as •the actual employer of the beneficiary.
  The beneficiary completed a two-year full-time secretarial training
program at the North-East Essex Technical College, Colchester, England in July 1957. Her program of instruction included typing,
stenography, accounting, and general commercial subjects. She has
been employed as a secretary by various firms in England since September 1957, and her employers have included a bank, a hospital, a
publishing house, and various commercial firms. The beneficiary in-

                                       772
                                               J.ILUITILLI. Lension.   *F.1.2510

tends to engage in her occupation in the United States as a secretary
having accepted a position with the Brook Street Bureau of Mayfair,
Ltd., New York New York.
   The occupation of secretary is on the list of occupations for which
the Secretary of Labor has precertified that there is a shortage of
employable and willing persons in the United States pursuant to section 212(a) (14) of the Act. The list of precertified occupations applies
to all areas of the United States unless a particular area is specifically
excepted. New York City is not an excepted area.
   The division of the petitioning company that furnishes specialized
and general office personnel to client firms on a temporary basis, guarantees to all of its personnel desiring it full-time permanent employment based upon the prevailing 35 to 37y2 hour week in New York
City. This was determined. from supporting documentation submitted
with the petition and from an interview of the petitioner's personnel
director at this office on May 6, 1968. In the first year of employment
the guarantee consists of a contract by the Brook Street Bureau to
pay an employee a guaranteed weekly wage based upon the prevailing
minimum 35 hour week even though the services of the employee may
not be assigned to client firms, but utilized. wi hin the offioes of the
Brook Street Bureau. In the second and succeeding years the petitioner meets the guarantee as a result of the currently prevailing high
demand for the services of skilled temporary office personnel. An officer of the petitioning company stated under oath that during her
three year tenure with the company, the Brook Street Bureau had
never failed to provide full-time employment to those requesting it
and that typical assignments range from several days to more than
three months.
   The beneficiary will be paid directly by the Brook Street Bureau.
Client firms are billed by the petitioner for the services provided them.
The petitioner is fully responsible for making contributions to the
employee's social security, workmen's compensation, and unemployment insurance programs as well as for withholding Federal and
State income taxes. The petitioner, furthermore, offers its personnel
involved in temporary client services an opportunity to subscribe to
   group insurance program and they receive a two week paid vacation upon the completion of 50 weeks of full-time employment.
   In view of the fact that the petitioner has guaranteed the beneficiary
full-time permanent employment for 52 weeks a year with a. two week
paid vacation and other fringe benefits and that the beneficiary will
be paid directly by the petitioner who is responsible for all payroll
deductions and contributions, it is concluded that the petitioner qualifies as the actual employer of the beneficiary within the meaning and
requirements of the Immigration and Nationality Act, as amended.
                                   773
Interim Decision 40875
Parenthetically, the division of the petitioner which deals only with
the referral of applicants to other employers as an employment agency
would not qualify as an actual employer when such applicants are
to be directly and permanently employed and paid by other individuals
or companies.
   It is further concluded that the offer of employment is not "of a
seasonal or temporary nature" as required by section 203(a) (6) of the
Act, as amended.
  ORDER: It is ordered that the sixth preference visa petition filed by
the Brook Street Bureau of Mayfair, Ltd. in behalf of Susan Mary
Smith be and bhe same is hereby approved.




                                 774

/12/indec/772 · .json · Public domain