Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 La. Ann. 765

Rayne v. Taylor

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided November 15, 1857

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1857-11-15

<p>Entries made by a Clerk in his employer’s books, are prima facie evidence in favor of the former against the latter, when it is shown that the books were annually examined by the employer and that balance-sheets were semi-annually furnished to him, which embraced the disputed items.</p>

Decided 1857-11-15

Spofford, J.

¶1There was no error in overruling the peremptory exception. There were no partnership accounts to settle, and it was competent for the plaintiff to demand the balance due him on the “loan account” merely. If there had been any equally liquidated sum due by the plaintiff to the defendant on other accounts, it might have been pleaded in compensation.

¶2The reconventional demand was unconnected with the main action, and was properly disregarded.

¶3It being proven that the books kept by the plaintiff’s son were annually examined by the defendant, who .spent a portion of his time each year in New Orleans, and that balance-sheets, including the account sued upon, were forwarded to him semi-annually, we think there was no error in admitting the books in evidence. The defendant appears to have found no fault with the entries when they were communicated to him. Coupled with the oral testimony they make out a prima facie case for the plaintiff, which has not been rebutted by evidence on the part of the defendant.

¶4There was error in allowing interest at the rate of eight per cent., in the absence of a legal contract to that effect.

¶5It is, therefore, ordered, that the judgment of the District Court be so amended as to reduce the interest upon the principal sum therein awarded, from eight per cent, to five per cent, per annum, and that, as thus amended, the said judgment be affirmed; the costs of this appeal to be borne by the-plaintiff and appellee.

Merrick, C. J., not present at the argument, took no partin the decision.
/12/laann/765 · .json · Public domain