Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

12 Tenn. 81

Parker v. Porter

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided February 15, 1833

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1833-02-15

The bill in this case was filed in the circuit court of Carroll county. The subject matter of the bill is unnecessary to be set forth, as the argument at the bar, and the decision of the court were based upon the correctness of the decision of the circuit court in dismissing the bill. The bill alleged that the defendants resided in Maury county. Subpcenas were issued to that county, and were there executed upon the defendants.

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently January 1996

2 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1833-02-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Green, J.

¶1delivered the opinion of himself, and Ca-tron, Ch. J. .The bill was filed in the circuit court of Carroll county, and states the residence of the defendants *83to be in the county of Maury. Process was served on the defendants in Maury county. The circuit court dismissed the bill for want of jurisdiction, on the motion of defendants.

¶2It is clear in this case the court had no jurisdiction over the persons of the defendants. Cooke Rep. 87, 339. The acts of 1825, ch. 22, and 1827, ch. 42, apply only to the chancery courts. They do not extend the jurisdiction of the circuit courts. The words “chancery courts,” used in these acts, do not mean all courts having and exercising chancery powers, but must mean the district chancery courts, as contradistinguished from the circuit courts.

¶3The court did right in dismissing the bill. On its face its shows the residence of the defendants, and the return of the process shows that it was served upon them in Maury county. Why proceed, when the court was thus compelled to perceive it had no jurisdiction; why require a plea in abatement? A plea states facts not appearing in the bill. In this case the plea would only be a repetition of the facts stated in the bill, it would have disclosed no additional fact, and was wholly useless and unnecessary. The court was bound to stop, so soon as it saw it had no jurisdiction df the case.

Whyte, J. dissented.

¶4Decree affirmed.

/12/tenn/81 · .json · Public domain