Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

122 Ga. 318

Donaldson v. Everett

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided March 6, 1905

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1905-03-06

Levy and claim. Before Judge Evans. Bulloch superior court. February 1, 1904. On December 14, 1901, Everett obtained a judgment against Donaldson. On December 19, 1901, the execution was levied on a Kimball organ. A claim was filed on December 12, 1902, and was tried in April, 1903. The plaintiff in fi. fa. assumed the burden, and proved that the property, when levied on, was in the possession of the defendant, who, as next friend for his minor children, filed the claim.

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently September 1928

3 state decisions

Relies on Hargrove v. Turner · Ross v. Cooley

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1905-03-06

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Lamar, J.

¶1(After stating the foregoing facts.) 1. A promise to give is not equivalent to an actual gift. In order for the title to pass there must be something to show that the gift was completed. In transactions between the father and minor children the law will dispense with some of the formalities of delivery usually required; yet even in such cases there must be some word or act to transfer title from donor to donee.. An intention to give is not sufficient. Civil Code, §3567; Hargrove v. Turner, 112 Ga. 134; Ross v. Cooley, 113 Ga. 1047.

¶22. In the present case the father purchased the organ in his own name, and gave his note therefor. It does not appear whether the purchase was before or after the lien of the judgment attached. Nor is there any evidence that he followed up his promise and made an actual gift to the children, so as to divest himself of the title acquired when he gave the note for the instrument. There is no complaint of the court’s charge. It *320was for the jury, under the evidence, to say, whether the claimant overcame the prima facie case made out by the plaintiff in fi. fa.

¶3Judgment affirmed,.

All the Justices concur, except Evans, J., disqualified.
/122/ga/318 · .json · Public domain