Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

122 La. 278

State v. Cibilich

Supreme Court of Louisiana

Decided November 4, 1908

Supreme Court of Louisiana · decided 1908-11-04

Miho C. Cibilich was convicted of receiving and keeping oysters in sacks not of standard measure,' in violation of Acts 1908, p. 135, No. 92, § 1, and lie applies for certiorari and prohibition.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently October 1917

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Judgment set aside, and defendant released · Decided 1908-11-04

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

PROVO STY, J.

¶1The defendant was tried on affidavit before the Second city criminal court, and was convicted. The judgment against him was affirmed on appeal to the criminal district court, and the case is before this court on writ of review.

¶2The affidavit charges that he did “knowingly, willfully, and falsely, fraudulently, and deceitfully receive, keep, and have in his possession certain oysters contained in sacks, which said sacks were not of the standard measure, as provided in section 1 of Act No. 92 of 1908.”

¶3To this affidavit the defendant demurred, as not charging any crime known to the law of Louisiana. Defendant also impugned the constitutionality of said Act No. 92, p. 134, of 1908, and, in fact, the validity of said act, even apart from any question of constitutionality, on various grounds.

¶4We think the demurrer should have been sustained. Neither said Act No. 92, p. 134, of 1908, under which the affidavit purports to have been drawn, nor any other statute, makes it a crime to receive, keep, and have in one’s possession sacks of oysters of less measurement than of any specified standard. At most, said Act No. 92, p. 134, of 1908, provides a measure, under penalty, for the sale of oysters, and for the importation of oysters in sacks. It no more provides a measure for receiving, keeping, and having oysters in sacks than it does for having them on the half-shell.

¶5Judgment set aside, aná defendant ordered released without day.

/122/la/278 · .json · Public domain