Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

123 Mass. 291

Prentice v. Brimhall

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 2, 1877

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1877-10-02

Contract. Writ dated September 27, 1875. The declaration alleged that on April 4, 1874, William S. Hillman, in consideration of $3000, to him paid by the defendant, executed to the defendant a deed of certain real estate in Worcester, and the defendant accepted the same; that the deed contained the following clauses: “ This conveyance is made subject to a mortgage for $1200, and interest since March 4,1874, and also a mortgage for $600, which the said grantee assumes and…

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently May 1893

7 state decisions

Relies on Exchange Bank v. Rich · Pettee v. Peppard

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1877-10-02

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1The defendant, by accepting the deed, made a contract with his grantor to pay the amount of the mortgages upon the land granted ; but the grantor transferred no money or fund to the defendant; and the defendant made no contract with the mortgagees or their assigns, upon which an action at law will lie. Mellen v. Whipple, 1 Gray, 317. Exchange Bank v. Rice, 107 Mass. 37. Pettee v. Peppard, 120 Mass. 522.

¶2In Felch v. Taylor, 13 Pick. 133, and Adams v. Adams, 14 Allen, 65, in which the acceptance of a devise of land, charged *294with the payment of an annuity or legacy, was held to create an implied promise upon which the annuitant or legatee could maintain an action against the devisee, the defendant had received property out of which to pay the plaintiff’s claim, and had made no contract with any other person, and, at the time of the first of those decisions, there being in this Commonwealth no jurisdiction in equity of such cases, a breach of the defendant’s undertaking could not have been effectually redressed in any other form than that which was sustained by the court.

¶3Judgment affirmed.

/123/mass/291 · .json · Public domain