Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

123 Mass. 443

Slack v. Slack

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided December 21, 1877

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1877-12-21

<p>In a probate appeal, the decision of a single judge on questions of fact will not be reversed, unless it is clearly shown to he erroneous.</p> <p>An intestate left a widow, to whom he was married in 1855, after having unlawfully cohabited with her for eight years. They lived together after marriage for about two years, when difficulties arising between them on account of his gross and confirmed habits of intoxication, which had existed throughout their cohabitation, they agreed that she should live apart from him for a year and then return. Before she went away, he withdrew his consent, but she insisted on leaving. At the end of the year she returned, but, finding that he had a housekeeper, with whom she believed him to be living in adultery, there being no bed in the house but his own, she went away and never returned, and was not asked to do so, but continued living apart from him, rendering him no services and supporting herself, until his death, which took place some years afterwards. She had no children by him, was in her seventieth year, and had no means of support. The Probate Court, upon the application of the widow, made ner an allowance of $350; and its decree was affirmed, on appeal by the administratrix, by a justice of this court. Held, upon appeal to the full court, that the decree should be affirmed, with costs.</p> <p>At the hearing on an appeal by an administratrix from a decree making an allowance to the widow of an intestate, evidence that the assets in the hands of the appet lant are insufficient to pay the allowance made to the appellee by the Probate Court is inadmissible, if the fact of such insufficiency is not stated as one of the reasons of the appeal.</p>

Relies on Allen v. Allen

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1877-12-21

How this case has been cited

Cited by 13 later decisions — most recently July 1915

13 state decisions

7018771880189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Colt, J.

¶1The evidence upon which the decree of the Chief Justice was based has not been reported. The report states all the facts deemed by him to be material on the question presented. All inferences of fact, and questions of discretion as well as of law, involved in the decree, are open to revision upon this appeal. But the decision of the single judge on questions of fact in a probate appeal, as in a suit in equity, will not be reversed, unless it is clearly shown to be erroneous. Wright v. Wright, 13 Allen, 207. Allen v. Allen, 117 Mass. 27.

¶2The statute gives a discretionary power to the judge of probate to make such allowance to the widow as he shall judge fit for the supply of necessaries for her use, “ having due regard to all the circumstances of the case.” The question how much shall be allowed must depend upon the varying circumstances of each case, with reference to wMch no general rule can well be stated. The fact that the parties lived separate, or which party was the culpable cause of the separation, may have little application to the question. “ The allowance,” as remarked by Shaw, C. J., in Hollenbeck v. Pixley, 3 Gray, 521, “ is not made to the widow as a reward for faithful service as a wife ; nor is it given out of the husband’s estate as compensation to her for ill treatment by him as a husband; but it is a question solely of her actual necessities.” Gen. Sts. c. 96, § 5.

¶3There is nothing in the facts reported in this case, which leads us to think that the decree of the Probate Court, or of the Chief Justice of this court, ought not to be affirmed. And there was no error in the ruling of the Chief Justice which confined *446the evidence offered by the appellant to the issues .raised by L. reasons of appeal.

¶4The widow having prevailed in this case, as in Allen v. Allen, 117 Mass. 27, in two successive appeals from a decree granting her an allowance, the decree of the Chief Justice, affirming the decree of the Probate Court, should he

¶5 Affirmed, with costs.

/123/mass/443 · .json · Public domain