Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

125 Ala. 119

Ex parte James

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided November 15, 1899

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1899-11-15

This was a petition filed in this court by L. D. James, asking for a writ of mandamus, addressed to the judge of the city court of Birmingham, requiring him to set aside an order in which he declined to consider a motion made by the petitioner. The facts of the case are sufficiently stated in the opinion. cited Ex parte Highland Ave. & B. R. R. Go., 105 Ala. 221; Allen v. Elliott, 67 Ala. 437.

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently June 1915

4 state decisions

Relies on Ex parte Highland Avenue & Belt Railroad · Allen v. Elliott

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1899-11-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

TYSON, J.

¶1Section 20 of the act approved February 28, 1889 (Acts, 1888-89, p. 1000), entitled “An act to amend an act entitled an act to establish the city court of Birmingham, approved December 9, 1884,” provides “that final judgments and decrees rendered in said court shall, after the expiration of thirty days from their rendition, be taken and deemed as completely beyond the control of the court, as if the term of said court at which said judgment and decrees are rendered had ended at the end of thirty *120days; provided, however, that nothing herein contained, shall prevent parties from applying for new trials or rehearings toitlmi said thirty days, or destroy or change the effect of motions for new. trials or rehearings when so made, or shall prevent parties from applying to said court for a rehearing under the statute authorizing applications for rehearing in the circuit court, or shall prevent the court from re-trying any cause under section 2871 of the Code of Alabama, or shall prevent the court from the exercise of any power or jurisdiction conferred upon the circuit court touching final judgments, or the chancery court touching final decrees.”

¶2On the 8th day of December, 1899, the presiding judge of the city court rendered a judgment dismissing a suit brought by this petitioner against the Shady Grove Baptist Church for want of prosecution. On the 3d day of January, 1900, the petitioner filed a motion in said city court to set aside this judgment. On the 6th day of January, 1900, written notice of the motion and the affidavits filed in support of it was served upon the attorney of record for the defendant. Qn the 8th day of January, 1900, the motion was presented to the court for consideration. It was not until this latter date that the motion was .brought to 'the attention of the court. On the objection of the defendant, the court declined to consider it upon the ground that more than thirty days had elapsed since the rendition of the judgent of dismissal.

¶3If thirty days had elapsed, there can be no serious doubt but that the court had no jurisdiction to disturb the judgment upon any of the grounds alleged in the motion. Ex parte Highland Avenue & Belt Railroad Co., 105 Ala. 221. We do not understand that petitioner’s counsel controvert this proposition. His contention is, that as the 30 th day expired on Sunday it must be excluded, and he had the next day in which to present his motion. The act makes no such exception, and section 11 of the Code has been construed by this court in Allen v. Elliott, 67 Ala. 432, as not supporting the contention. It was said in that case, speaking of this section: “The statute, we think, was intended merely as a reaffirmation of the common law rule, that, while Sun*121days are generally to be computed in the time allowed for the performance of an act, if the last day happens to be Sunday, it is excluded, and the act must be performed on tlie day previous.”

¶4Whatever of merit there may be in the assault made upon the soundness of this construction of the statute, we are univilling at this late day to depart from it, as the statute has twice been re-enacted by the General Assembly since the rendering of the opinion in that case.

¶5The writ of mandamus must be denied.

/125/ala/119 · .json · Public domain