Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

125 Mich. 80

Gregivere v. Chalker

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided October 31, 1900

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1900-10-31

<p>Sheriffs — -Action on Bond — Failure to Return Execution.</p> <p>* In a suit upon a sheriff’s bond for failure to return execution, under section 890, 1 Comp. Laws 1897, the return was duly made by the officer, but the justice failed to enter that fact upon his docket. Upon the trial the justice produced the execution, which had been in his possession since its return. Held, that the failure of the justice to minute the return upon his docket did not bind the officer, and it was competent to show in defense a return duly made.</p>

Relies on Grand Rapids Chair Co. v. Runnels · Stolte, Dangel & Foss Co. v. Cochran

Affirmed · Decided 1900-10-31

Grant, J.

¶1(after stating the facts). Appellant’s-counsel contends that the proffered testimony impeached *82or contradicted the justice’s docket, and was therefore inadmissible, under Stolte, Dangel & Foss Co. v. Cochran, 111 Mich. 193 (69 N. W. 347), and authorities there cited. The cases referred to, as well as others, are cases where it was sought to contradict the record made by the justice, or to supply the statutory requirements to his jurisdiction. They do not apply to a suit brought against a sheriff under the above statute, where he has performed his duty. This case is rather within the rule of Grand Rapids Chair Co. v. Runnels, 77 Mich. 104, 117 (43 N. W. 1006), where it was contended that the execution was void because the justice’s record did not contain an entry that the justice ever issued it, and the court held that this failure did not vitiate an execution actually and properly issued. The law does not punish an officer for the neglect of a justice. The execution being found in the justice’s office, with a proper return thereon, made within the prescribed time, renders it unnecessary to determine whether the officer could testify to what he did under the execution.

¶2Judgment affirmed.

The other Justices concurred.
/125/mich/80 · .json · Public domain