Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

126 Mass. 523

Golden v. Blaskopf

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1879-05-09

Writ of review to reverse a judgment recovered by the defendant in review against the plaintiff in review. Trial in the Superior Court, without a jury, before Pitman, J., who allowed a bill of exceptions in substance as follows: The original action was begun by an attachment of the defendant’s property on March 13, 1876. The defendant gave a bond to dissolve the attachment, and the writ was returned and entered.

Relies on Ray v. Wight · Brainard v. Bushnell · Page v. Cole

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1879-05-09

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently April 1950

6 state decisions

20187918801890190019101920193019401950decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1The objections taken would have been more properly presented at the hearing of the petition for a review, but, assuming them to be now open, they cannot avail.

¶2The judge before whom the case was tried without a jury has found as matter of fact that the suggestion of bankruptcy was filed before the rendering of the original judgment. If that suggestion had been brought to the notice of the court before the actual entry of judgment, the case must have been continued to await the result of the proceedings in bankruptcy, and the suggestion could not have been defeated by an entry of judgment nunc pro tuna. U. S. Rev. Sts. § 5106. Ray v. Wight, 119 Mass. 426. Clinton National Bank v. Taylor, 120 Mass. 124. Page v Cole, 123 Mass. 93. The suggestion of bankruptcy not having been brought to the notice of the court until after judgment had been entered, a review might properly be granted for the purpose of enabling the proceedings in bankruptcy to be set up by way of defence. Gen. Sts. c. 146, § 21. Todd v. Barton, 117 Mass. 291. Shurtleff v. Thompson, 63 Maine, 118.

¶3It is contended, upon the authority of Edwards v. Reginam, 9 Exch. 628, and Wright v. Mills, 4 H. & N. 488, that the judgment took effect as of the earliest minute of the day on which it was rendered, and therefore in law took precedence of the suggestion of bankruptcy filed at ten o’clock on the same day. It is not clear that it would be allowed such an effect in England in an action between individuals. Green v. Laurie, 1 Exch. 335. Robson on Bankruptcy (3d ed.) 504. In this country, fractions of a day are usually regarded, when necessary for the ends of justice. Bigelow v. Willson, 1 Pick. 485, 495. Brainard v. Bushnell, 11 Conn. 16. Lemon v. Staats, 1 Cowen, 592. And if the judgment could by a technical rule have the unjust operation contended for, it was certainly within the discretion of the court to grant a writ of review in order to prevent that consequence.

¶4The previous agreement of the parties for the entry of judgment, although it might, according to the decision in Hall v. Wolcott, 10 Mass. 218, have been a waiver of a review as of right, could not control the discretion of the court in granting a review upon petition.

¶5Exceptions overruled.

/126/mass/523 · .json · Public domain