Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

127 Ga. 537

Hall v. Lockerman

Supreme Court of Georgia

Decided January 16, 1907

Supreme Court of Georgia · decided 1907-01-16

<p>.1. A ward who had arrived at age employed attorneys to bring suit against her guardian and the sureties on his bond. After the attorneys were employed, and both before and after the suit was filed, the ward stated to one of the sureties that no claim would be made against him, and that if any judgment was obtained it would not be enforced against him, and that he need not feel any uneasiness on account of the suit. The surety -filed a plea in the suit, and the assurances above referred to were again made after the plea was filed. Relying upon these assurances, he did not press his defense. A judgment was taken against the guardian and all of the sureties, and, while the surety above referred to was in the court-room when this judgment was taken, he did not .know that the judgment was in fact rendered against him as well as ■the other defendants. The surety filed an equitable proceeding to set aside the judgment. The ward did not resist this proceeding. The attorneys employed by her filed an intervention, in the nature of both a demurrer and an answer, in resistance to the petition to set aside the judgment, alleging that they had a lien upon the suit and the judgment, which could not be defeated by any act of their client after the suit was filed. Upon a trial the jury found a verdict to set aside the judgment. The attorneys moved for a new trial, which, being refused, they excepted. Held: (a) The petition set forth a cause-of action; and as there was evidence to sustain the contentions of the surety in reference to the assurances given him by the ward, there was no error in overruling the motion for new trial. (6) While the attorneys had a lien upon the suit, the existence of this lien would be no reason for allowing them to enforce a judgment against the surety which was rendered as a result of his being lulled into security by assurances by their client that no claim would be made against him. (c) Attorneys have a lien upon all suits brought by them and all judgments obtained upon a. real cause of action in behalf of their client, but they have no right to enforce a judgment obtained by surprise when the defendant has been, by the act of their client, deprived of the right to be heard on the existence of a cause of action at the time of their employment and at the time of the beginning of the suit.</p> <p>2. The charges excepted to were not erroneous- for any reason assigned. The-requests to, charge, even if they contained correct propositions of law, were inapplicable to the facts of the case. There was no error in any of the rulings on evidence, and no sufficient reason has been shown for reversing the judgment.</p>

Decided 1907-01-16

Atkinson, J.

¶1After a statement of the case, there 'is room for but little discussion. The equitable amendment set forth a cause of action, and, if true, furnished sufficient grounds for the equitable relief prayed for. The excerpts from the charge of the court do not contain any error of law, for any reason assigned, and they are properly adjusted to the pleadings and proof. The rulings of the court upon the admissibility of evidence were not erroneous for any reason assigned. The requests to charge, so far as they state' correct principles of law, are not 'applicable to the facts. Hall and George were not parties to the suit on the bond, and, while they had a lien upon the suit filed, and the client, without their consent, had no right to settle the ease so as to interfere with the lien, still, when the client notified the defendant Loekerman that she had no claim against him and did not intend to prosecute the suit against him, thereby lulling him into security, and, as he testifies, causing him not to press his defense, it would be wrong under such circumstances to allow a judgment to stand against him for the benefit of either the client or the attorneys. The attorneys had 'no interest in the case except in that which the client could recover. The interest of the attorneys was wholly dependent upon *543a right of recovery by the client. If the client had no cause of action against the surety, she acquired none merely by the employment of an attorney to represent her, and her attorneys’ rights were no greater than hers. The surety had a right, as against both the client and the attorneys, to be heard on the existence of a cause of action at the time the suit was filed. If the conduct of the client has been such that the defendant would be entitled to have the judgment set aside, the judgment in its entirety must be set aside. This would especially be the case where, by the conduct of the client, the defendant was prevented from interposing a defense, and from relying upon the defense already filed, upon which he was entitled to be heard, which, if sustained, would defeat the client .altogether, or at any rate reduce the amount of recovery to be had. If the client is defeated and can recover nothing against the defendant, the attorney is necessarily defeated. In the light of what has just been said, we do not deem it necessary to further discuss the rulings of the court hereinbefore referred to. When the suit on the bond goes to trial, under the judgment of the court to which exception is taken the attorneys may prosecute the case for the purpose of establishing a liability upon the part of the defendant to the plaintiff, to the end that they may ascertain and recover their fees, while, on the other hand, the defendant may insist upon his defenses for the purpose of defeating a recovery in part or in whole.

¶2 Judgment affirmed.

All the Justices concur, except Fish, G. J., absent.
/127/ga/537 · .json · Public domain