Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

128 Ind. 304

McCollum v. Uhl

Indiana Supreme Court

Decided April 1, 1891

Indiana Supreme Court · decided 1891-04-01

<p>Drainage. — No Notice. — Collateral Attach. — An order made establishing a ditch without notice to those interested is void; but if only part have i / •> *. been notified, it is void as to all those who have not received notice. Those who have not received notice may attack the proceeding collaterally.</p> <p>Same. — Collateral Attach for Want of Notice. — Pleading.—The person who collaterally attacks an order establishing a ditch and the assessments incident thereto, because of lack of notice, must aver in his complaint, fully and specifically, that no notice was given.</p> <p>Same. — Notice.—Presumption as to Giving, and as to the Order Establishing the Dram. — In a collateral attack upon an order establishing a ditch, and making an assessment, it will be presumed that the court establishing the ditch found, as a jurisdictional fact, that a notice was duly given before it entered the order.</p> <p>Same. — Priority of Tax; and Ditch Lien. — The lien of the State for taxes is paramount and superior to the lien of a ditch assessment.</p> <p>Same. — Redemption from Tax Sale by Holder of Ditch Lien. — -The holder of a ditch lien has a right to redeem from a sale of the land for taxes.</p> <p>Same. — Foreclosure of Tax Lien. — Parlies to Ditch Proceeding. — Party Acquiring Ditch Lien. — The holder of a tax lien seeking to foreclose it after a ditch is established, andbefore its construction islet, should make parties to his petition all who were parties to, and affected by, the ditch proceedings; and any person acquiring the ditch lien, or any part of it, by reason of his having constructed the ditch, after the commencement of the proceeding to foreclose the tax lien, will not be bound thereby, unless the parties to the ditch proceedings are made parties to the tax lien foreclosure proceedings.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1891-04-01

How this case has been cited

Cited by 16 later decisions — most recently December 2014

16 state decisions

501891190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1On Petition for a Rehearing.

McBride, J.

¶2Appellee’s counsel have filed a very earnest and ingenious brief in support of their petition for a rehearing. They say two question are involved:

¶31st. Is it possible to extinguish the lien of a ditch assessment by the foreclosure of a superior tax lien ?

¶42d. Who are necessary parties to a suit for that purpose?

¶5There can be no doubt that it is possible to extinguish the lien of a ditch assessment by the foreclosure of a superior tax lien. No such question confronts ¿us in this case, for the reason, as stated in the original opinion, that there was no attempt to foreclose the tax lien as against the ditch assessment.

¶6Counsel now say: “Where a lien such as a ditch assessment exists, and has not reached the period of vesting, the effect of foreclosing a superior lien is not to bar an equity of redemption — none exists — but to extinguish the lien itself.”

¶7The error in appellee’s position is, that he assumes that *310there can be a valid ditch assessment in which no one has an interest entitling him to be made a party to the proceeding seeking its extinguishment, and that it is possible, by a decree of court, to extinguish the lien of such assessment without having before the court any of the parties interested in it. The complaint shows the establishment, by order of the board of county commissioners, of a ditch across the land in question, and that the sum of $261.53 was assessed against it as the proportion properly chargeable thereon fo.r the construction of the ditch. This the complaint also, shows was done long before the proceeding was commenced to foreclose the tax lien. All who were beneficially interested in the construction of the ditch were interested in the assessment thus made against the particular land.

¶8A ditch established by order of the board of county commissioners, for the drainage of wet lands, although it may pass over the lands of many men, and be divided into many allotments for its construction, and the cost of construction may be apportioned to many different tracts, yet it is to be considered as an entirety, and the several allotments and assessments as parts of an entire system. For instance, suppose the allotment to the land in question was of the terminal section of the ditch, and unless it was constructed there would be no outlet, could it be said that the owners of lands living above and assessed for the construction of the ditch had no proprietary interest in such terminal allotments ?

¶9If appellees contention is right, after a ditch has been established a section may be cut out of it, or the outlet destroyed by the foreclosure of a tax lien upon some one of the tracts of land through which it is laid, in a proceeding to which none of those interested in the construction of the ditch are parties, although, as to the remaining tracts, the owners may still be compelled to construct their allotments, or, indeed, may have already done so. If this is true, thei’e is at least oxxe case in which the property rights of a citizen may be taken from him without due px’ocess of law. We *311can not assent to such doctrine. In our opinion the petitioners, and other parties to the proceeding, assessed for the construction of the ditch, had such an interest in the assessment in question that its lien could not be extinguished by the foreclosure of the paramount lien without giving them their day in court.

Filed May 10, 1891.

¶10The petition for a rehearing is overruled.

/128/ind/304 · .json · Public domain