Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

128 Mass. 240

Wright v. Herrick

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 19, 1880

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1880-01-19

<p>A. bought goods of B., informing him that the business was his, and that it would be carried on by C. in A/s name. Subsequently C. formed a partnership with another person, and A. revoked C.’s agency, and directed him not to use his name, and had no more connection with or knowledge of the business or the name in which it was carried on by C. and his partner. A. gave no notice of any change to B., who, without notice or knowledge of the change, continued in good faith to sell goods to the firm on the credit of A. The firm also bought goods of D., who gave credit to A. B. brought an action against A. and attached goods as his property. D. afterwards brought an action against C. and his partner, doing business under the name of A., and attached the same goods. B. was then allowed, without notice to D., to amend his writ by adding the names of C. and his partner as defendants, and declaring against all three as doing business under the name of A. Both B. and D. recovered judgments As between C. and his partner, and A., the latter had no interest in the attached goods. D. requested the attaching officer to apply the proceeds of the property in satisfaction of the execution obtained on his judgment. This the officer declined to do except in part, but first applied the same in satisfaction of the execution obtained by B. on his judgment. D. then brought an action against the officer; and, at the trial, asked the judge to rule that the relation of A. to 0. and his partner, as to B., was that of principal and agent, and not that of partnership; that, if A. was liable at all, he was liable individually as principal, and C. and his partner, if liable at all, were liable as agents, but that B. must elect to hold either the principal or the agents, and could not hold bo1h; and that the attached property, being the property of the agents, could not be levied upon to satisfy B.’s execution. The judge declined so to rule, and found for the defendant. Held, that D. had no ground of exception.</p>

Relies on Wright v. Herrick

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1880-01-19

How this case has been cited

Cited by 3 later decisions — most recently October 1915

1 federal appellate · 2 state decisions

101880189019001910decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Endicott, J.

¶1The facts in this case, though substantially the same, differ in some respects from those disclosed when the case was last before us. 125 Mass. 154.

¶2It appears that, in the autumn of 1872, Henry Phillips purchased goods of Plumstead, and informed him that the business was his, and would be carried on by William W. Phillips in his name. It was not distinctly stated in the bill of exceptions, but it is to be inferred, that William W. Phillips had authority to use, and did use, his name in the purchase of goods. In the spring of 1873 the business was transferred to William W. Phillips and Edward Martin, who had formed a partnership to carry it on, and the authority of William. W. Phillips, as agent, was revoked, and he was directed by Henry Phillips not to use his name. After this, Henry Phillips had no connection with, or *243knowledge of, the business, and did not know in what name it was carried on by William W. Phillips and Martin. The new firm carried on the same business as Henry Phillips. Of this change Plumstead had no notice, and, without any knowledge of the change, continued to sell goods to the new firm, and charged them to Henry Phillips. Whether Henry Phillips gave notice of this change to the plaintiffs, or to other persons who had sold goods to him does not appear, but it is evident that William W. Phillips and Martin continued to use his name in carrying on their partnership business in the same manner as it had been carried on before; for it is stated in the bill of exceptions that the debts of the plaintiffs and of Plumstead, on which their judgments were obtained, were contracted in the name of Henry Phillips, who had no interest in the attached goods, which was not known to Plumstead. It is fairly to be inferred from this statement, that they were sold to both on the credit of Henry Phillips, and it was so stated in the former opinion; and the plaintiffs cannot well deny that William W. Phillips and Martin carried on business under the partnership name of Henry Phillips, for they are so described in the writ upon which their attachment was made. The goods were sold by Plumstead in good faith to the firm on the credit of Henry Phillips, and were the same that were attached and sold by the defendant’s deputy.

¶3Upon these facts and findings, we cannot say that the court below was bound, as matter of law, to give the ruling requested. Having refused to give that ruling, the court might well find for the defendant. Exceptions overruled.

/128/mass/240 · .json · Public domain