Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

128 Mass. 421

Commonwealth v. Washburn

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided February 27, 1880

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1880-02-27

Complaint to a trial justice-, averring that the defendant, on August 15, 1878, at Needham, “did keep a male dog, contrary to the provisions of the statute passed in the year 1868, being chapter 130 of the Acts of the General Court of said Commonwealth, passed in that year, and entitled ‘An Act concerning dogs, and for the protection of sheep and other domestic animals,’ in that he, the said Washburn, being on the first day of May, 1878, the owner of a male dog, and keeping…

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently April 1926

1 federal appellate · 1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1880-02-27

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Gray, C. J.

¶1If the complaint had set forth the facts necessary to constitute an offence under the St. of 1867, c. 130, or under any other law of the Commonwealth, the mistake in stating the year of the passage of the statute might have been deemed to be either surplusage, which might be disregarded, or else a formal defect, which, not having been objected to before the trial *422justice, could not be availed of in the Superior Court. 2 Hale P. C. 172. St. 1864, e. 250, § 2. Commonwealth v. Walton, 11 Allen, 238.

¶2But this complaint in no way avers or shows that the defendant has been guilty of any offence whatever, nor even what acts he has done or omitted to do, except by reference to the provisions of a statute passed in the year 1868, which is referred to, not merely as a law governing the case, (of which, if it existed, the court might be bound to take notice,) but as the only description in fact of the acts or omissions of the defendant. There being no statute of that year upon the subject, the complaint, if not bad in substance, as matter of law, is unsupported by the evidence, as matter of fact. 2 Hawk. c. 25, § 104. Gould PL c. 3, § 171. Commonwealth v. Hartwell, ante, 415.

¶3Exceptions sustained.

/128/mass/421 · .json · Public domain