Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

129 Ala. 627

Kelly v. Johnson

Supreme Court of Alabama

Decided November 15, 1900

Supreme Court of Alabama · decided 1900-11-15

•Tried before the Hon. J. C. Richardson. This was an action brought by the appellee, I. D. Johnson, against the 'appellant, R. A. Kelly. The complaint as originally filed contained two counts.

Relies on State ex rel. Porter v. Crook · Burns v. Reeves

Decided 1900-11-15

SHARPE, J.

¶1—)

¶2Under the 'authority of Hamilton v. Griffin, 126 Ala. 600; and Burns v. Beeves, 127 Ala. 127, it must 'be held that the cause of action declared on in the complaint was within the class of demands which by section 8728 of the 'Code is made subject to the defense of set-off. The striking out of the 3d plea was, therefore, error.

¶3The statement offered as testimony of Rushing relates to acknowledging satisfaction of mortgages which had been -paid and not to the failure to enter credits 'of partial payments on the unpaid mortgage of 1896 described in the second count, which after the 'amendment of the complaint contained the Whole cause of suit. For that .reason, if for no other, the statement was immaterial and was properly excluded.

¶4For»the error referred to the judgment will be reversed and the cause remanded.

¶5Reversed and remanded.

/129/ala/627 · .json · Public domain