Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 Abb. N. Cas. 371

Hearn v. Sullivan

New York Supreme Court

Decided January 15, 1884

New York Supreme Court · decided 1884-01-15

<p>Motion to set aside Taxation of Costs.—Costs on Reference of disputed Claim against Estate ; Taxation, now REVIEWED.</p> <p>Where an order, confirming a referee’s report in favor of defendants directs “ that the defendant have judgment for costs and disbursements of this action against the plaintiff,” it is not error for the clerk to tax costs as in an action, as the order is his guide; if costs should have been taxed as in a special proceeding, the remedy is by-appeal from the order, and not by motion to set aside the taxation.</p> <p>Whether a reference of a disputed claim against an estate under 3 R. S. 89, §37, be deemed a “special proceeding ” or an “ action,” the court has power, under Code Civ. Pro. § 3340, to award costs “asin actions brought in the same court.”</p>

Decided 1884-01-15

Westbbook, J.

¶1The clerk did not err in allowing costs as in an action. The order of the special term, awarding costs, was his guide. The order was “ that the defendants have judgment for costs and disbursements of this action.” The order designates the proceeding as “an action,” and the remedy, if any, was by appeal from the order, and not by appeal from the taxation of this clerk, and thus to ask one special term to overrule another.

¶2But the order of the special term was right. It is unnecessary to discuss the question whether this proceeding was a “special proceeding” or an “action,” for the statute (3 R. S. [6 ed.] 97, § 48), has declared that when costs are awarded in such a matter they shall be “as in actions against executors,” and although it was a “special proceeding,” the court had power (Code Civ. Pro. §3240) to award costs “as in actions brought in the same court.”

¶3Motion denied, with $10 costs.

/13/abbncas/371 · .json · Public domain