Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 Abb. Pr. 166

Moores v. Lunt

New York Supreme Court

Decided June 15, 1872

New York Supreme Court · decided 1872-06-15

Demurrer to complaint. This action was brought upon a bond given to discharge an attachment issued against the steamship Metropolis, to enforce a lien for materials sold in the city of New York for said steamship, then in course of construction in the State of Massachusetts. When the vessel came to this port an attachment was issued against her, therefor, under the act of 1862; and the bond in suit was given to procure her release.

Decided 1872-06-15

Brady, J.

¶1The Metropolis was lying upon the stocks, unfinished, and in the course of construction, when the contract referred to was entered into and performed.

¶2The claim is for materials furnished to a vessel before launching, and while on the land, and is not, therefore, maritime in its nature (Sheppard v. Steele, 43 N. Y., 54; see also Brookman v. Hamill, Id., 554).

¶3If the materials had been delivered at Newburyport, in the State of Massachusetts, the objection that the debt was one not contracted within this State, might be plausible under the ruling in Mullin v. Hicks (49 Barb., 250); but it is alleged, and admitted by the demurrer to be true, that the articles named were furnished in this State,—to wit: at the city of New York,—for and towards the building, fitting out, furnishing and equipping of the vessel. It assumes, the character of a transaction by which the plaintiff undertook to make certain articles, and to deliver them at the city of New York to some person authorized to receive them for transportation.

¶4These acts,—namely, the manufacture and delivery here,—would make the debt, beyond all doubt, one contracted within this State.

¶5The decision of the court of appeals in the case of The Josephine (39 N. Y., 19), is explained and limited *169in Brookman v. Hamill (supra), and its operation confined to cases in which the claim is strictly maritime.

¶6The demurrer, for these reasons, must be overruled, with leave, however, to the defendants to answer in ten days on payment of the costs of the demurrer.

¶7Ordered accordingly.

/13/abbpr/166 · .json · Public domain