Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 Iowa 504

McShane v. Gray

Supreme Court of Iowa

Decided June 26, 1862

Supreme Court of Iowa · decided 1862-06-26

<p>'X. Referee: acquiescence. The report of a referee should not be set aside on the ground that the reference was to but one person when it should have been to three, if it appears that no objection to such reference was made at the time, and that the party complaining appeared before the referee and submitted the cause on his part.</p> <p>2. Referee’s report. It is competent for the court to require a referee to state the facts found as the predicate for the final judgment; but in the absence of such requirement a general finding will be sufficient.</p>

Decided 1862-06-26

Wright, J.

¶1It was competent, by consent of parties, to refer the action to one referee, instead of three. (Code, § 1594.) And when such reference has been made, and the party afterwards raising the objection, failed to signify •the same at the time, but, on the contrary, appeared before the referee, and submitted his cause, his mere suggestion, by motion, that the submission was irregular and unauthorized, should not be received with favor, nor entertained.

¶2It was competent for the court to require the referee to state the facts found, as the predicate for the final judgment. This was substantially done in this case. But if not, as there was no requirement to this effect, the report would still be valid. The referee may, in the absence of instructions, state a general finding of so much for one party or the other, and upon this the court can render judgment.

¶3In what respect the finding of the referee was contrary to law, or why defendant’s set-off was improperly rejected, is not suggested, and the judgment must stand

¶4Affirmed.

¶5Vol. XIII. 64

/13/iowa/504 · .json · Public domain