Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 Mass. 204

Willis v. Twambly

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1816-05-15

<p>fi minor being possessed of a promissory note, payable to himself and not negotiable, exchanged it with A. for a watch which was worthless. The next day he tendered the watch to A. and demanded the note, to neither of which A. acceded. The maker of the note, being informed of the transaction, and receiving a discharge from the minor’s father, gave a new note for the debt. A afterwards passed the first note to B. assuring him that it would be paid. B. sued the maker in the name of the minor, and the Court held, that the note was void from the rescinding of the contract by the minor.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1816-05-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently July 1942

9 state decisions

3018161820183018401850186018701880189019001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Parker, C. J.,

¶1delivered the opinion of the Court. Whether this note or promise was ever assigned, so as to enable Cook or Raynes to maintain an action against the promissor, even in the name of Willis, the minority of Willis being put out of the question, we need not now determine. There was no assignment in writing, nor any signature of Willis on the instrument, over which an assignment could be written, nor any promise by Twambly to pay any person but Willis. Whether the mere manual delivery of the evidence of a contract, although intended to operate as a sale or transfer, could authorize a suit in the name of Willis, is a question of some doubt.

¶2But we are all clearly of opinion, that, had the assignment been ever so formal, it might be rescinded by the minor, it being a contract by which he could not be bound ; and that the note ceased to be the property of Cook, from the time when he was notified by Willis, that he considered the bargain void, and was tendered the watch, which was the consideration of the bargain. The settlement made by Twambly, when he gave a new note in lieu of this, discharged him from liability on this contract. For, although he then knew that the note had passed to Cook ; yet he had a right to consider the property of it as still remaining with Willis; it not being negotiable in its nature, and the transfer having been vacated. Between Cook and Twambly there could be no question. * Nor do we think that Raynes stands in a better light.

¶3Every man, who takes an instrument not by the terms of t assignable, must take it principally upon the credit of the party from whom he receives it ; for it is always liable to be defeated by equitable circumstances, subsisting between the original contracting parties; the assignee being subject to the same equity as the assignor. Twambly’s defence against Cook would have been perfect by show ing a payment of the note to Willis, after notice to Cook that the bargain was recalled. And he has the same defence against Raynes, who, purchasing the note without the name of Willis upon it, ought to have inquired into the title of Cook, and to have applied to Willis himself, to know whether he had fairly parted with it, in order to save himself from loss.

¶4The affirmation of Cook, however, may entitle Raynes to an action against him, that affirmation appearing to be false.

¶5*169Whether the indorsement by an infant of a negotiable promissory note, or other mercantile instrument, can be avoided, so as to prejudice a bona fide indorsee, who is ignorant of the minority of the indorser, is a different question from the one now presented, and may require further consideration.

¶6In the case brought before us by this writ, there is no error affecting the judgment, in the opinion of the Court as delivered to the jury , and the judgment must, therefore, be affirmed, with costs for the defendant in error.

/13/mass/204 · .json · Public domain