Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 S.C.L. 373

Ware v. Key

Supreme Court of South Carolina

Decided May 15, 1823

Supreme Court of South Carolina · decided 1823-05-15

; Tried at Abbeville, Spring, 1823. THE note on which this action was founded, was drawn by the defendant and payable to the plaintiff, or bearer. It appeared from the evidence that the plaintiff had passed the note by delivery, to Wm. Powell for a valuable consideration. The action was brought by the executors of Powell, who died before the commencement of this lection, who were now prosecuting it.

Decided 1823-05-15

Mr. Justice Johnson

¶1delivered the opinion of the court :

¶2The general rule is that an action can only be maintained in the name of him in whom, by the terms of the contract, the legal interest is vested, (1 East. 497. % Term 711.) Upon this principle, choses in action not being assignable at common law, actions on them could only be maintained in the name of the original parties, (1 Cbitty on Pleading, 10-11,) notwithstanding the actual interest had been passed by assignment, delivery, &e. And it is only under the several legislative provisions on this subject, that the assignees and holders of choses in action, are permitted to bring actions in their own names, and none of these contain any provisions'which take away the right to proceed according to the rule of the common law.

¶3Our courts have always regarded the assignment of. a chose in action, not negotiable as. aletter ofattorney to the assignee. The assignee or holder of one that is negotiable, may therefore elect to regard himself in that character or sue in his own name under the authority of the statutes and acts authorizing it.

Noble ¿y Wardlaiu, for the motion.Downs, contra.

¶4Superadded to this motion, was one for a new trial, on the ground that the defendant proved the pay n-ent. Tic's ground is clearly without support, as the preponderance of the testimony was against it.

¶5The motion is refused.

Justices Colcock, Noll, Gantt, Richardson and Huger, ■concurred.
/13/scl/373 · .json · Public domain