Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

13 Tenn. 108

Porter v. Wheaton

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided March 15, 1833

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1833-03-15

Porter warranted Wheaton. On the trial, Wheaton's account was the larger by three dollars eighteen cents. The justice gave judgment for the amount for defendant. This occurred 18th May, 1827. On the 6th June, Porter applied to two justices to bring the cause into the county court.

Decided 1833-03-15

Catron, Ch. J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Was the foregoing excuse for not prosecuting the ordinary remedy by appeal, sufficient? The great object is not to incur ruinous costs in litigating small matters; wherefore the parties must be compelled to appear before the justices and there end the controversy. Were this party permitted to say he did not know the time and place of trial when he was plaintiff, and make this an excuse for heaping on Wheaton the costs of court, it is difficult to conceive an excuse not sufficient to bring up the cause by certiorari. We deem the excuse offered for not attending the trial, investigating Wheaton’s cross demand, and appealing if plaintiff was injured, wholly insufficient. Reverse the judgment of the circuit court, and affirm that of the county court.

¶3Judgment reversed.

/13/tenn/108 · .json · Public domain