Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

132 N.Y.S. 744

Westervelt v. Shapiro

Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York · decided 1912-01-09

Supplementary proceedings by Whitley P. Westervelt, judgment creditor, against Isaac Shapiro, judgment debtor. Motion by the judgment creditor to resettle an order of the Supreme Court, Appellate Term (132 N. Y. Supp. 338), modifying and affirming an order of the City Court of the City'of New York refusing to vacate a subpoena issued to Sophie Shapiro and an order adjudging her in contempt for failure to appear pursuant to the subpoena from which she' appealed.

Decided 1912-01-09

LEHMAN, J.

¶1I have no doubt but that the Appellate Court has power to modify the order by imposing a different fine from that erroneously imposed by the court below, but ordinarily the function of determining the amount is best exercised by the court in which discretion is lodged in the first instance. In this case the amount of $510 was part of the fine actually imposed. The order of this court should have reversed the order of the court below, with costs and disbursements and remitted the proceeding to the court below for the imposition of such fine as lies within the discretion of the court below, unless the respondent stipulates to reduce the fine to the sum of $510. The order cannot, however, be modified by fixing a definite fine, and remitting the proceeding to the Special Term to fix an additional fine.

¶2Motion to resettle in form proposed denied. All concur.

/132/nys/744 · .json · Public domain