134 N.C. 683
47 S.E 16
Supreme Court of North Carolina
Decided March 29, 1904
Supreme Court of North Carolina · decided 1904-03-29
<p>INTOXICATING LIQUORS — Instructions—Questions for Jury.</p> <p>An instruction, on a prosecution for unlawfully keeping liquor for sale, that if defendant had whiskey in his possession he would be guilty of keeping it unlawfully, was erroneous, it being for the jury to determine from all the evidence whether he was guilty as charged.</p>
From a verdict of guilty, and judgment thereon, the… · Decided 1904-03-29
¶1 His Honor said to the jury that the first question to decide was “whether the man had the whiskey in his possession; if he did, that would make him guilty of keeping it unlawfully.” The defendant excepted.
¶2 In any point of view the instruction was erroneous. The jury should have been permitted, upon the whole of the evidence, to say whether or not the defendant was guilty as charged. Por this error, without passing upon the other exceptions, there must be
¶3 New trial.