Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

135 Mich. 226

Finkbinder v. Ernst

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided December 22, 1903

Michigan Supreme Court · decided 1903-12-22

Case by Charles Finkbinder against Christian Ernst for the wrongful flooding of plaintiff’s land. From a judgment for plaintiff, defendant brings error. This unfortunate and expensive controversy between neighbors is before us for the second time. The issue and the facts are sufficiently stated in the opinion then rendered. 126 Mich. 565 (85 N. W. 1127). The record in that case did not contain all the evidence.

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently November 1913

4 state decisions

Relies on Runnells v. Village of Pentwater

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1903-12-22

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1on application for rehearing.

Grant, J.

¶2The briefs of counsel in this case were prepared and filed upon the understanding that Runnells v. Village of Pentwater, 109 Mich. 514 (67 N. W. 558), was still the law; that that decision was neither overruled nor changed by statute. We disposed of the case upon that understanding. A motion for rehearing was made upon the same understanding. Some days after the motion was made, a supplemental brief was filed, calling our .attention to Act No. 52 of the Public Acts of 1901, which *230provides that it shall not be necessary to except to the re: fusal of a court to give requests to charge, but that error may be assigned without excepting thereto upon the trial. In their supplemental brief counsel for defendant say that they had overlooked this statute. They now insist that the assignments of error based upon the refusal to give certain of their requests be considered on account of this statute.

¶3Speaking for myself, I would deny the rehearing where the case was submitted upon the mutual understanding as to the rule of practice, and mutual ignorance of a statute modifying a decision of the court. My Brethren, however, are of the opinion that they should comply with the statute. We have therefore examined the requests and the charge of the court. Some of these requests are directly in conflict with the charge of the court as found in the opinion. The instruction of the court below we held to be a correct statement of the law. We do not deem it essential to give these requests or to discuss them. It is sufficient to say that the instruction of the court covered the entire ground and correctly stated the law, and there was sufficient conflict of evidence to submit the case to the jury.

¶4Rehearing denied.

Moore, G. J., Carpenter and Montgomery, JJ., concurred. Hooker, J., did not sit.
/135/mich/226 · .json · Public domain