Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

136 Mass. 173

Commonwealth v. Jones

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided December 4, 1883

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1883-12-04

<p>If two persons are jointly indicted for larceny, and one of them pleads guilty, the other cannot be convicted without proof of joint action with the former in the larceny of which he has pleaded guilty.</p> <p>A., B., and C. were jointly indicted for larceny. At the trial there was evidence that, after their arrest, A. and B. were placed in adjoining cells; and thereupon A. said to B., “What did you tell the old man” (meaning the owner of the stolen property) “ about me 1 ” B. replied, “ I told him nothing; ” and A. then said, “ I guess C. has given us away.” B. pleaded guilty, and C. was acquitted. Held, that this was not sufficient evidence of any joint action of A. with B.</p>

Decided 1883-12-04

By the Court.

¶1The defendants Jones and Meroth could not legally be convicted, under the same indictment, of separate and independent offences. Meroth having pleaded guilty, Jones could not be convicted except upon proof that he was a joint actor with Meroth in the larceny of which the latter was convicted.

¶2There is not sufficient evidence of this fact. The evidence of the government tended to show separate larcenies by Jones and Meroth, at separate times, without joint action with each other. The only evidence of any joint action was a conversation between Jones and Meroth, stated in the bill of exceptions. This conversation is equally consistent with the hypothesis that they had committed separate larcenies, known to each other and to Stencil, as with the theory that they had committed a joint larceny. It cannot fairly be said to prove the latter beyond a reasonable doubt.

¶3The exception taken by Jones is important, because this conviction would not be a bar to another indictment against him for a separate larceny.

¶4 -Exceptions sustained.

/136/mass/173 · .json · Public domain