Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

136 Mo. App. 209

Phoenix Stone & Lime Co. v. Huggins

Missouri Court of Appeals

Decided February 1, 1909

Missouri Court of Appeals · decided 1909-02-01

— No». Thomas J. Seehorn, Judge. (1) The record in this cause printed and filed by the appellant fails to show the filing of a motion for a new trial, or the filing of a bill of exceptions, and therefore the exceptions relied upon by the appellant cannot be reviewed in this court, and there being no error assigned on the record proper the judgment should be affirmed. Harris v. Kobusch, 127 Mo. App. 441; Ellman v. Schultz, 127 Mo. App. 203; In re Boeckenkamp, Est., 127 Mo.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently November 1913

1 state decisions

Relies on Harding v. Bedoll · Stark v. Zehnder · Pennowfsky v. Coerver

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Affirmed · Decided 1909-02-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

ELLISON, J.

¶1This action is on an account for cut stone furnished defendant at his instance and request. The judgment in the trial court was for the plaintiff.

¶2*210The abstract of the record presented here does not show by the record proper that any motion for new trial was filed, or that there was a bill of exceptions filed. The bill of exceptions shows those things, but it has been ruled a great number of times that they must be shown by the record proper.

¶3Defendant presented at the hearing a paper denominated a supplemental abstract. This was done without consent and cannot be noticed. [Thompson v. Ruddick, 213 Mo. 561, 111 S. W. 1131; Olay v. Pub. Co., 200 Mo. 665; Stark v. Zehnder, 204 Mo. 442; Stark v. Martin, 126 Mo. App. 575; Harding v. Bedoll, 202 Mo. 630; Pennowfsky y. Coerver, 205 Mo. 135; City of Macon v. Jaeger, 133 Mo. App. 643, 113 S. W. 1138; Gray v. Railway (decided this term).]

¶4There being no error in the record proper, the judgment is affirmed.

All concur.
/136/moapp/209 · .json · Public domain