Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

136 Tex. 97

147 S.W.2d 769

Clements v. Williams

Texas Supreme Court

Decided February 12, 1941

Texas Supreme Court · decided 1941-02-12

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““It will be noted that the opinion [of the Court of Civil Appeals] says ‘and the note and contract provided that the holder could mature the entire debt upon failure to pay any monthly installment when due.’ We have examined the note, and we find that the Court of Civil Appeals in its opinion inadvertently used the word debt when it intended to use the word note. The default maturity clause in the note provides that the holder at his election may ‘mature said note, and it shall at once become due and payable .... ’ Such default maturity clause permitted the holder of this note to mature all installments as written in it, including unearned interest .... Such an instrument is usurious in its inception. [Citation omitted.] If the default maturity clause had merely provided for the maturity of the debt, the note would not be usurious because unearned interest could not be collected. [Citation omitted.]” Id. (emphasis that of the Court).”

quoted by 2 later decisions, including Jim Walter Homes, Inc. v. Schuenemann, Jim Walter Homes, Inc. v. Schuenemann

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1941-02-12

How this case has been cited

Cited by 19 later decisions — most recently December 1997

3 federal appellate · 16 state decisions

110194119501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

per curiam :

¶1 The opinion of the Court of Civil Appeals (146 S. W. (2d) 215) makes the following statement: >

“Appellant testified that there was added to the $1,236.81 principal enough interest to make the face value of the note $1,457.50, which was to be amortized by monthly payments of $27.50 each, which monthly payments included both principal and interest; and the note and contract provided that the holder could mature the entire debt upon failure to- pay any monthly installment when due.”

¶2 It will be noted that the opinion says “and the no;fce and contract provided that the holder could mature the entire debt upon the failure to pay any monthly installment when dife.”

¶3 We have examined the note, and we find that the Court of Civil Appeals in its opinion inadvertently used the word debt, when it intended to use the word note. The default maturity clause in the note provides that the holder at his election may “mature said note, and it shall at once become due and payable ….” Such default maturity clause permitted the holder of this note to mature all installments as written in it, including unearned interest. This resulted in providing for a contingency under which more than ten per cent, interest per annum could be collected. Such an instrument is usurious in its inception. Shropshire v. Commerce Farm Credit Co., 120 Texas 400, 30 S.W. (2d) 282, 84 A. L. R. 1269, rehearing denied 120 Texás 412, 39 S. W. (2d) 11, 84 A. L. R. 1269. If the default maturity clause had merely provided for the maturity of the debt, thp note would not be usurious because unearned interest could not be collected. Walker v. Temple Trust Co., 124 Texas 575, 80 S. W. (2d) 935.

¶4*99 The application for writ of error is dismissed w. o. j.— CORRECT JUDGMENT.

¶5 Opinion delivered February 12, 1941.

/136/tex/97 · .json · Public domain