Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

137 Mass. 551

Case v. Stevens

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 5, 1884

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1884-09-05

Tort, in two counts. The declaration was as follows: “ And the plaintiff says that on or about the ninth day of May, 1882, he bargained with the defendants to buy of them a certain bay mare about seven years old, which then appeared to the plaintiff to be all sound and kind, and the said defendants, by then and there warranting the said mare to be all sound and kind, deceitfully sold the same to the plaintiff for the sum of two hundred and fifteen dollars.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently February 1899

1 state decisions

Relies on Allen v. Truesdell

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1884-09-05

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

W. Allen, J.

¶1This is an action of tort for a breach of a warranty that a horse sold by the defendants to the plaintiff was kind. It is alleged that the defendants knew that the warranty was false. The only damage alleged is for the breaking of the plaintiff’s wagon and harness in consequence of the unkindness of the horse; and the plaintiff claimed no other damages in the court below. The court ruled that such damages could not be recovered upon the facts alleged; and the only question is upon the correctness of that ruling.

¶2The ruling was correct. The warranty related only to the value of the horse, and there is nothing in the declaration to show that it was given or received in view of anything else. The only damage in consequence of the breach of it, which is brought within the contemplation of the parties, is the diminution in value of the property warranted. The declaration contains no allegations which bring it within the principle of Allen v. Truesdell, 135 Mass. 75, and other cases of false representations or warranties of fitness for particular uses contemplated by the parties. Exceptions overruled.

/137/mass/551 · .json · Public domain