Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 Johns. 166

Drake v. Barrymore

New York Supreme Court

Decided May 15, 1817

New York Supreme Court · decided 1817-05-15

IN ERROR, on. certiorari to a justice’s court. Barrymore brought in an action of trespass, * before the justice, against Drake, Corwin, and Curry, for taking and carrying away the plaintiff’s hog. The defendants in the court below pleaded not § The defendants then offered to prove, that Corwin and Curry were trustees of a school district, and had regularly issued a warrant to Drake, as collector of that district, and that he took the hog by virtue of that warrant.

Cited by 1 later decisions — most recently December 1895

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1817-05-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1The justice erred in deciding, that upon a joint plea of not guilty, two of the defendants could not be acquitted, though there was no evidence against them. (1 Chitty, Pl. 75. 3 East Rep. 62. Cowp. 610.) There is a distinction in this respect,' between a joint plea of the general issue, and a joint plea-of justification. In the latter case, if the plea is not supported as to all, neither of the defendants can be protected under it. (Schemerhron and others v. Trip, 2 Caines Rep. 108. 1 Saund. 28. n. (2.)

¶2As to the second point, the justice decided correctly, that the justification, under the collector’s warrant, could not be admitted under a plea of not guilty. It is not a case within the statute, allowing to certain public officers that privilege; and the act relative to common schools, which creates these officers, is' *167silent in this respect. The judgment must therefore be reversed on the first ground. - - -

¶3In returning that the plaintiff had released two of the defend~ ants from the judgment, the justice went beyond his office. The plaintiffs in error have no opportunity of controverting that fact, or questioning its legal effect. We cannot therefore, take notice of it on this record.

¶4Judgment reversed.

/14/johns/166 · .json · Public domain