Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 Johns. 233

Van Ankin v. Westfall

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 15, 1817

New York Supreme Court · decided 1817-08-15

THIS was an action of slander tried before Mr. Justice Platt, at the Orange circuit, in September, 1816. The words charged in the three first counts of the declaration, and proved, on the trial, to have been spoken, 'by the de fendant, of the plaintiff, were, the plaintiff is a thief, and has stolen fifty dollars in cash from Jacob De Witt. These words were spoken in this state, -but had reference to a transaction which took place in Pennsylvania, where Jacob De Witt resided.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1817-08-15

How this case has been cited

Cited by 7 later decisions — most recently June 1895

7 state decisions

30181718201830184018501860187018801890decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This is an action of slander, charging the for saying of the plaintiff, 11 He is a thief, and has stolen fifty dollars in cash from Jacob De (VittIt appeared, in proof, that Jacob De Wiil resided in the state of Pennsylva-nia ; and that the transaction referred to by the defendant took place in that state. The plaintiff’s right to sustain the action was objected to, because no crime was alleged against him for which he could be punished here. This objection was proper-ly overruled. Although the plaintiff might not be amenable to our law, had the charge against him been true ; yet, from any thing that appears, he might have been demanded as a. fugitive from justice, and have been punished, if guilty, in the state of Pennsylvania. But the right of the plaintiff to sustain the does not depend upon the question, whether he was liable to be prosecuted and punished for the crime charged against him. As when the statute of limitations has run against the ■ .criminal prosecution, it is still slander to charge the party with the offence; and the party making the charge would have a righi to justify, and show the truth of his allegation, the criminal prosecution might be barred. The offered in mitigation of damages was properly overruled. The testimony was to show the truth of the charge alleged against the plaintiff, and was not admissible under the general issue, in justification; and it is a well-settled rule that the truth of the charge is not admissible in mitigation of damages. The •motion for a new trial must, accordingly, be denied.

¶2Motion denied.

/14/johns/233 · .json · Public domain