Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 Johns. 246

Collins v. Ferris

New York Supreme Court

Decided August 15, 1817

New York Supreme Court · decided 1817-08-15

IN ERROR, to the court of common pleas of the county of Chenango. This was an action of trespass de bonis asportatis, brought by dol-lars, direct-ed the defendant in error against the plaintiff in error, a justice of the peace of the county of Chenango, for illegally issuing an against the defendant in error, the plaintiff below. The cause was tried in the October term, 1816, of the court below.

Cited by 2 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently May 1889

1 state decisions

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1817-08-15

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Per Curiam.

¶1This case comes before the court on a writ of error to the common pleas of Chenango county, and the question submitted to this court arises under a bill of exceptions tendered to the court below. The action was trespass, de bonis asporlalis, against the defendant below for issuing an attachment under the 33d section of the 25 dollar act, (1 R. L. 398.,) without having any other proof of the departure of the defendant than the oath of the plaintiff in the attachment. It is unnecessary here to determine whether the justice, by this procedure, made himself a trespasser or not ;(a) for the judgment must be reversed for misdirection to the jury, as to the rule of damages.

¶2In the attachment, the arms and accoutrements of the defendant were expressly excepted. But the constable, notwithstanding, attached a "military coat and cap, though the same were not taken out of the possession of the former when found. The court below charged the jury that the plaintiff was entitled to recover against the justice damages for the taking and detaining the coat and cap. In this direction the court below erred. The justice neither commanded nor ratified this act; but, on the contrary. all such articles were expressly excepted out of the attachment. If any damages are to be recovered for such taking, the justice cannot be responsible. Recourse must be had to the constable. Although the damages recovered on this account were probably small, yet, as it is very evident the justice acted in good faith, and under a belief that he was complying with the requisites of the act, he is justifiable in defending himself under all legal, objections, though they may appear somewhat technical. The judgment of the court below must be reversed.

¶3Judgment reversed,'

¶4 Vide, Vosburgh v. Welch, 11 Johns. Rep. 175.

/14/johns/246 · .json · Public domain