Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 Mass. 374

Commonwealth v. Smith

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided September 15, 1817

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1817-09-15

This was a writ of certiorari, issued at the instance of Smith, the respondent, W. E. Green, Esq., a justice of the peace for this county, to bring up the proceedings had before the said justice, upon the complaint of Edward D. Bangs, clerk of a company of light infantry, against the said Smith, alleging him to have been duly enrolled in the said company, and to have unnecessarily neglected to appear at. a muster of the company on the 7th day of May 1816, although duly…

Decided 1817-09-15

Parker, C. J.

¶1We think the appointment to the place of an engine-man gives an exemption from military duty, as well in independent or volunteer companies as in those of the standing militia, they being different modifications only of the same duty; and that the enlistment being voluntary makes no difference, as it was merely a choice of the mode in which he would perform his service in the militia; also that the 14th article of the 34th section must be construed to operate upon exemptions existing at the time of the enlistment, they being waived by the enlistment. In the case before us, the appointment was subsequent to the enlistment; and this new duty gave the right to be exonerated from militia service.

¶2But we think that the provision in the section containing the exemptions, that engine-men must produce annually a certificate of their appointment, was intended to protect the commander and clerk of the company from trouble and expense, which might be incurred by causing prosecutions where they might have no knowledge of the exemption; and that the period of eight days allowed by the statute is applicable to excuses, and not to exemptions, which need no excuse.

¶3We are of opinion, therefore, that, at the time of the muster or training, for absenting himself from which the respondent was adjudged to pay a fine, he was not exempt, not having then produced his certificate to the commanding officer of the company.

¶4Proceedings affirmed.

/14/mass/374 · .json · Public domain