Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

14 N.Y. St. Rep. 425

Witherbee v. Slayback

New York Supreme Court

Decided February 15, 1888

New York Supreme Court · decided 1888-02-15

Jus.tice Fish, November 22, 1887, striking out certain portions of the fourth paragraph of the answer herein as irrelevant. The action is brought against defendants as directors of a corporation, known as the Port Henry Steel and Iron Company, limited, to charge them with the debts of such corporations, by reason of its failure to file certain annual reports.

Decided 1888-02-15

Landon, J.

¶1The matter stricken out adds nothing to the completeness of the statement of the defense set up in the answer. It appears to be a recital of evidence tending to establish that defense.

¶2It is urged, however, that, in a certain aspect of the case, the matter stricken out might constitute a defense separate from the one pleaded. It may be the suggestion of a possible defense, but is not a defense well pleaded. As it now stands, it is matter irrelevantly and improperly annexed to a defense.

¶3We affirm the order with costs, with leave to the defendants to amend their answer as to such suggested defense, within twenty days from the service of a copy of the order upon them, if they be so advised, but without change of date of issue.

¶4Learned, P. J., and Ingalls, J., concur.

/14/nystrep/425 · .json · Public domain