Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

142 Mass. 515

Williams v. Williams

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 22, 1886

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1886-10-22

<p>Appeal, by George R. Williams, from a decree of the Probate Court, allowing the will of Theodore Williams. The case was heard, and reported for the consideration of the full court, by Field, J., who found the following facts:</p> <p>The testator executed three wills, each of which he published and declared to be his last will and testament; and each of them contained a revocatory clause. The third will was made subsequently to the will in contest, which was the second will. At the time the testator executed the third will, he said, “ I will keep the three until I make up my mind which I want, and then I will destroy the two I do not want.”</p> <p>All these facts were found upon the testimony of a single witness, whom the judge believed to be accurate and truthful. If the fact of the execution of the third will and its containing a revocatory clause can be established by the oral testimony of a single witness, by the same testimony the entire contents of the third will can be established, as the witness testified to its entire contents.</p> <p>The testator afterwards destroyed the first and third wills. The will in contest "was produced, proved to have been duly executed, and the testator was proved to be of sound mind and of full age. The second will was found eight days before he died, crumpled up on the floor of the water-closet at his home, but under such circumstances that the judge found that there was no intention to destroy it.</p> <p>There was no evidence that the testator ever republished or revived the second will after the destruction of the will last made, except that above stated; namely, that he said, at the time he executed the third will, that he would keep them all until he made up his mind which he wanted to keep, and would destroy the two wills he did not want, and keep the other, and the fact that the first and third were destroyed, and the second was not.</p> <p>The judge found that the testator intentionally'destroyed the first and third wills, and retained the second, intending to revoke the first and third, and to retain the second as his last will; and affirmed the decree of the Probate Court.</p>

Relies on Pickens v. Davis

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1886-10-22

How this case has been cited

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently December 1949

10 state decisions

301886189019001910192019301940decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

C. Allen, J.

¶1There was proof, satisfactory to the mind of the justice who heard the case, that the testator, in cancelling his last will, intended to revive the former one which he then left uncancelled; and his conclusion of fact was well warranted by the evidence. Such proof may come from a single witness ; Brown v. Brown, 8 El. & Bl. 876; Burns v. Burns, 4 S. & R. 295; and, being found sufficient to establish the fact, the legal result follows that the former will is thereby revived. See Pickens v. Davis, 134 Mass. 252, and authorities there cited; 2 Am. Lead. Cas. (4th ed.) 709, & seq. The fact that the testator executed three wills at different times, all of which were kept by him for a time uncancelled, and that, when he executed the third will, he said that he would keep them all until he made up his mind which he wanted to keep, and would destroy the two he did not want, did not have the legal effect to place the three wills on an equal footing as unexecuted and unpublished wills. The last will, if left unrevoked, would be valid.

¶2 Decree affirmed.

/142/mass/515 · .json · Public domain