Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

147 Mass. 479

Smith v. Whitney

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided October 19, 1888

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1888-10-19

<p>Lease of Land—Removal of Building at end of Term — Trade Fixtures.</p> <p>A lease of land provided that the lessee might make additions and alterations in a wooden building thereon, which were to enure to the benefit of the premises at its expiration, and that he might erect other buildings on it for manufacturing purposes and remove them within a limit thereafter. The lessee altered and enlarged the wooden building and fitted it with machinery for a box factory, and erected near it a brick engine-house, complete in itself and wholly unconnected therewith, except that a tin flashing attached to the side of the wooden building was fitted closely to the roof of the engine-house to protect it from the weather. The engine and boiler were placed on solid foundations of masonry, the boiler was connected with an iron smoke stack running through the roof, and the engine was coupled with the machinery by belting and shafting. Held, that the engine-house was not an addition to the wooden building, but a building which the lessee had a right to remove, and that the boiler and engine, as well as the machinery, were removable trade fixtures.</p>

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1888-10-19

How this case has been cited

Cited by 4 later decisions — most recently March 2007

1 federal appellate · 3 state decisions

101888189019001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

W. Allen, J.

¶1We are of opinion that the engine-house was not an addition to the lumber-house, but a building which the defendant had a right under the lease to remove. The lumber-house was a wooden building, and extensive alterations and additions were made to it, and it was fitted with machinery for a box factory. The building in question was erected near to it, and was not, in its construction or in its use, a part of it. It was built of brick, complete in itself, and was not connected *482with the other building. Its only use was as a house for the engine which furnished power to the factory, and which was connected with the machinery in the factory by belts and shafting. The engine and machinery were trade fixtures, which could be removed by the defendant. The fact that the engine was so connected with the machinery in the factory did not make the engine-house a part of the factory building. On the contrary, the purpose of its erection, for the protection of a fixture which could be removed as personal property of the defendant, as well as the manner of its construction, shows that it was not an addition to the lumber-house, but a building which the defendant could remove before or after he should remove the engine.

¶2 Exceptions overruled.

/147/mass/479 · .json · Public domain