Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

148 A.D. 864

Siede v. Newkirk

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · decided 1912-02-02

Abbeal. by the plaintiff,, Henry Siede, from an order of- the1 Supreme; Court,. made at the New- York Special- Term and! entered1 in. the office; of the: clerk: of the- county of New York on the 29 th day of November,-1910, ¿Denying the plaintiff’s motion made upon defendant’s papers to vacate an order for the- examination: of the plaintiff: before' trip!

Decided 1912-02-02

Scott, J.

¶1(dissenting):

¶2I dissent. I do not think that it is entirely clear that everything defendant can elicit by an examination of plaintiff are matters which plaintiff must prove as part of his case. In any event, if plaintiff has just cause for complaint, no injustice will be done by his examination.

¶3Ingraham, P. J., concurred.

¶4Order reversed, with ten dollars costs and disbursements, ■ and motion granted, with ten dollars costs.

/148/ad/864 · .json · Public domain