Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

15 I. & N. Dec. 359

AKINOLA

Board of Immigration Appeals

Decided July 1, 1975

Board of Immigration Appeals · decided 1975-07-01

Cited by 2 later decisions — most recently December 1994

1 federal appellate ·

Relies on 11 I. & N. Dec. 493 - BRANTIGAN

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1975-07-01

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

                                                            Interim Decision #2400




                              MATTER OF AKINOLA
                          In Visa Petition Proceedings
                                      A-18159092
                        Decided by Board June 19, 1975

The District Director revoked his approval of visa petition classifying beneficiary as the
 spouse of a United States citizen under section 201(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act, on the ground that the beneficiary had a prior marriage which had not
 been dissolved. The beneficiary and his first wife, natives and nationals of Ghana, had
 been married there in 1964 according to local tribal custom. Beneficiary entered the
  United States as a nonimmigrant student in 1969, and was later that year joined by his
 first wife. He claims they were divorced in 1972, under Ghanaian customary law, at a
 time when neither he nor his first wife was in Ghana. He married petitioner in 1973. The
 proofs offered as to the termination of the first marriage were found to be insufficient.
  Board held that petitioner had failed to sustain the burden of proof as to termination of
 prior marriage, citing Matter of Brantigan, 11 L & N, Dec. 493 (BIA 1966) and 8 CFR
 204.2(c)(2). Board stated that as a minimum, to establish termination of a Ghanaian
 tribal marriage by a tribal divorce, there must be proof of confirmation by a Ghana
  Court, or proof of the customary law of the pertinent Ghana tribe or group and proof of
 compliance with such law.
ON BEHALF OF PETITIONER:          Ira Ehrlich, Esquire
                                  2140th Street
                                  New York, New York 10016


   In a decision dated December 11, 1974, the district director revoked
approval of a visa petition classifying the beneficiary as the spouse of a
United States citizen under section 201(b) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. The district director revoked approval on tha ground
that the beneficiary had a prior marriage which has not been dissolved.
The petitioner has appealed from that decision. The appeal will be
dismissed.
  The beneficiary is a native and citizen of Nigeria. He married his first
wife in Ghana in 1964 according to local tribal custom. The beneficiary
entered the United States as a nonimmigrant student in January 1969.
His first wife joined him later that year. The petitioner claims that the
beneficiary divorced his first wife under Ghanaian customary law on
June 6, 1972. At the time, neither party was in Ghana. The petitioner
married the beneficiary on October 5, 1973.
   In a visa petition proceeding, the burden of proof is on the petitioner.
                                          359
Interim Decidon #2400

Matter of Brantigan, 
11 I. & N. Dec. 493
 (BIA 1966). Under 8 CFR
204.2(c)(2), the petitioner must submit proof of the legal termination of
all previous marriages of both the husband and spouse.
   As evidence of the termination of the beneficiary's marriage, the
petitioner has submitted affidavits from the parents of the beneficiary,
the parents ehis first Wife, and a letter from the Consulate General of
Ghana in New York. The affidavits state that the beneficiary and his
first wife were divorced in June 1972 and that they are no longer
husband and wife. Both affidavits are dated June 6, 1972. The letter
from the Ghanaian consulate states that the dissolution of the marriage
is authenticated by the affidavits of the parents.
   The district director revoked approval on the ground that the divorce
did not conform to the customary law of Ghana. Specifically, the district
director found the purported divorce was defeCtive because the parties
had failed to confront the families, and that it had not been shown that a
"severance drink" had been presented or that the family of the wife had
returned the marriage gift to the family of the husband.
   Counsel for the petitioner maintains that a divorce under the customary laws of Ghana is executed solely by the parents of the divorcing
couples and that the other requirements alluded to by the district
director are Lot needed to effect a divorce. Neither the petitioner -nor
the district director cites any legal authority for their respective positions.
   We have consulted the Library of Congress which has furnished us
with a memorandum, dated June 2, 1975, concerning customary divorce
in Ghana, as well as copies of relevant Ghana statutes: According to the
memorandum, the District Courts of Ghana have been given jurisdiction
over divorces governed by customary law. Under the Courts Act,
section 50(2), the court is empowered to make broad inquiry to determine the customary rule of law to be employed, since customary law will
vary from place to place and tribe to tribe. Once the court is satisfied
that the relevant customary law has-been followed, the divorce may be
granted.                                                  .       .
   The Library of Congress memorandum indicates that it is possible to
effect a customary Ghanaian divorce without recourse to the courts.
However, proof of such a divorce absent confirmation by a Ghanaian
court, requires that the parties establish the. ethnic group or tribe to
which they belong, the customary divorce law of such tribe or group,
and evidence that the pertinent customary laws were conformed to.
Apparently, according to the memorandum, non-judicial customary divorces require the execution of certain ceremonial formalities to be
effective.
  The petitioner, who bears the burden of proof, has met none of the
foregoing requirements. Neither a judicial decree of divorce, nor a

                                  360
                                                 Interim Decision #2400

confirmation of a non-judicial divorce has been submitted. The petitioner has not substantiated the claim that there was a non-judicial
customary divorce by submitting evidence of the customary law of
divorce of the tribe to which the beneficiary or his first spouse belonged.
   While we do not hold that a Ghanaian tribal or customary divorce may
be established only by a Ghanaian Court decree, we do note that the
courts of Ghana are the body best equipped•to determine the validity of
a customary divorce. Absent such a Court decree, or confirmation by a
Ghana Court, the petitioner must submit proof of the customary law of
the pertinent Ghana tribe or group and proof that such law was conformed to. See Matter of Annang, 14 I. & N. Dee. 502 (BIA 1973).
   The result reached by the district director was correct. The appeal
will be dismissed.
   ORDER: The appeal is dismissed.




                                  961

/15/indec/359 · .json · Public domain