Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

15 Tenn. 271

State v. Duncan

Tennessee Supreme Court

Decided August 15, 1834

Tennessee Supreme Court · decided 1834-08-15

The defendants were indicted for gaming in Warren county. They pleaded in abatement to the indictment, that Lewis Thomas, one of the grand jury, who found the indictment, was not a freeholder or householder.— This plea was demurred to by the attorney general. The demurrer was overruled, and the plea sustained by the circuit court. From the judgment of the circuit court, overruling the demurrer, the attorney general prosecuted a writ of error to this court.

Decided 1834-08-15

Catron, Ch. J.

¶1delivered the opinion of the court.

¶2Formerly it was required that grand jurors should be freeholders. The act of 1809, ch. 119, declared eve*275ry white male citizen, being a householder, and twenty-one years of age, shall be deemed legally qualified to act as a grand or petit juror, except in cases, the venue of which has been changed.

¶3Suppose an indictment was found by a grand jury, no person composing of which was qualified? All will admit the indictment would be merely void in fact, and ought not to be answered if the fact was made legally to appear. So if any one be incompetent, it is equally void, because the proper number to constitute the grand inquest is wanting; and because he who is incompetent shall not be one of the triers of the offence at any stage of the prosecution. There seems at some early stage of the proceeding by indictment, to have been some doubt whether the indictment was void, because of the incompetency of one of the grand jurors, to set which at rest, the II Henry 4, ch. 9, enacted, “that any indictment taken by a jury, one of whom is unqualified, shall be altogether void and of no effect.” 1 Chitty’s Crim. Law, 307: State vs. Bennett, Martin and Yerger’s Rep. 135.

¶4The authorities cited shew, that the proper, and almost only mode of taking advantage of the objection is by plea in abatement. The judgment, therefore, must be affirmed.

¶5Judgment affirmed.

/15/tenn/271 · .json · Public domain