Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

151 A.D. 808

Getman v. Getman

Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York · decided 1912-06-27

Appeal by the plaintiff, Nancy Catharine Getman, from a judgment of the Supreme Court in favor of the defendant, entered in the office of the clerk of the county of Fulton on the 20th day of November, 1911, upon the decision of the court, after a trial at the Fulton Special Term.

Decided 1912-06-27

Per Curiam:

¶1The controversy between the parties as it then existed, was properly disposed of by the learned trial court. The plaintiff, however, has some rights under the will of .her father which the defendant is bound to observe, and it is proper for us to define them as the plaintiff requests.

¶2The devise of the farm to the defendant was charged with the board of the plaintiff and the right to occupy the specified portion of the house and the payment of the sum named. The defendant accepted the devise and thereby bound himself to perform its conditions. He need not perform them, however, unless the plaintiff wished him to, and she having voluntarily left the farm and chosen to reside elsewhere, the defendant could not be put in default until a proper demand was made that he allow the plaintiff to reoccupy her rooms in the house and that he furnish board to her. The notice of January, 1911, was not sufficient for that purpose. The defendant appears to have recognized his obligation to do these things, for in his lease of the farm he reserved the rooms for plaintiff’s occupancy and provided for her board.

¶3There is no proof that the tenant was not a suitable person for the plaintiff to board and live with, and the defendant was not obliged personally to reside on the farm in order to *810furnish boárd for the plaintiff, nor to furnish it elsewhere if he was ready to furnish it at the farm.

¶4It is necessary that the plaintiff make a new demand in order to put the defendant in default in case of refusal, and, therefore, we cannot modify the present judgment as suggested, but must affirm it, with costs.

¶5All concurred.

¶6Judgment unanimously affirmed, with costs.

/151/ad/808 · .json · Public domain