Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

152 So. 3d 969

152 So.3d 969

2013 La.App.1Cir. 1328

Wilkerson v. Buras

Supreme Court of Florida

Decided August 12, 2014

Supreme Court of Florida · decided 2014-08-12

Cited by 5 later decisions — most recently April 2019

5 state decisions

Relies on 95 So. 3d 539 - Argence, L.L.C. v. Box Opportunities, Inc. · 57 So. 3d 1181 - Hinds v. Global International Marine, Inc.

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 2014-08-12

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

GUIDRY, J.,

¶1dissenting in part.

¶2Lin order to preserve the lawsuit in this case, the majority relies on the date a judgment was filed into the record, rather than the date on which the judgment was signed or rendered, citing to Hinds v. Global International Marine, Inc., 10-1452 (La.App. 1st Cir.2/11/11), 57 So.3d 1181. In Hinds, however, the date used was the date of the ruling. In particular, the court in Hindsobserved that a ruling on a party’s motion remained pending “until May 14, 2007, when the order was marked ‘MOOT,’ returned unsigned to the Clerk of Court, and filed on May 17, 2007” Hinds, 10-1452 at p. 2, 57 So.3d at 1183 (emphasis added). The court in Hindsconcluded that the step initiated concluded on the date the court ruled on the plaintiffs motion and that abandonment began to run anew on the day after the court ruled on the plaintiffs motion. Hinds, 10-1452 at p. 6, 57 So.3d at 1185. As pointed out, the court was well aware *979and even observed the date the ruling was filed into the record, yet this later date was not used in Hindsas the date for commencing the running of the period for abandonment.

¶3Somewhat in line with Hindsis a fourth circuit opinion that held that it was the hearing date rather than the date the prevailing party filed the proposed | ¿judgment or even the later date of when the proposed judgment was signed that commenced the running of the period of abandonment. Argence v. Box Opportunities, Inc., 11-1732, p. 4 (La.App. 4th Cir.5/23/12), 95 So.3d 539, 541. Therefore, I respectfully dissent.

/152/so3d/969 · .json · Public domain