Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

153 S.W. 412

Cotton v. Garza

Court of Appeals of Texas

Decided January 30, 1913

Court of Appeals of Texas · decided 1913-01-30

<p>1. Limitation op Actions (§ 180*) — Raising Defense — Special Exception.</p> <p>Certain items in an amended statement were specially excepted to as barred by limitations; but the original statement, filed in justice court, was not in the record. It did not appear that such items were not included in the original statement, which would have prevented their being barred. Held, that the exceptions were properly overruled, since the defense of limitations can 'be raised by special exception only when the bar is disclosed by the face of the petition.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — For other cases, see Limitation of Actions, Cent. Dig. §§ 670-675, 681; Dec. Dig. § 180.*]</p> <p>2. Appeal and Error (§ 742*) — Assignments of Ebboe — Proposition.</p> <p>An assignment of error, not supported by a proposition, will not foe considered.</p> <p>[Ed. Note. — For other cases, see Appeal and Error, Cent. Dig. § 3000; Dec. Dig. § 742.*]</p>

Affirmed · Decided 1913-01-30

HIGGINS, J.

¶1 Appellee filed suit in justice court for the recovery of double the amount of certain payments alleged to have been made as usurious interest. Upon appeal to county court, judgment was rendered against appellant in the sum of $34.52. Appellant excepted specially to certain of the alleged payments upon the ground that the same appear to have been paid more than two years prior to the filing of the suit.

¶2 [1] The defense of limitation must be specially pleaded; but it may be raised by special exception when the bar is disclosed by the face of the petition. The items against which the exceptions are directed were alleged in an amended statement; but the original statement, as filed in the justice court,, is not contained in the record. The items, which it is claimed were barred by limitation may have been covered by the original statement, and, if so, they would not have been barred; and, since the amended statement does not disclose that they were not contained therein, it therefore follows that they do not, upon the face of the statement, *413 appear to be barred, and tbe exceptions were therefore properly overruled.

¶3 Tbe fourth and fifth assignments present no reversible error, and the same are overruled.

¶4 [2] The sixth assignment of error is unsupported by any proposition, and is therefore not considered. The seventh assignment, complaining of the refusal of a special charge, is overruled. We have examined that portion of the statement of facts to which we are referred for the evidence, which it is contended demanded such a charge, and fail to' find any supporting the same. The eighth, ninth, and tenth assign.ments are without merit, and are overruled. The eleventh is too general, and is not considered.

¶5 Affirmed.

/153/sw/412 · .json · Public domain