Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

155 Mass. 287

Commonwealth v. Baker

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 6, 1892

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1892-01-06

<p>Complaint — Gaming — ‘1 Policy ” — Burden of Proof— A ccomplice.</p> <p>A complaint to the “ Municipal Court of the city of Boston, holden at said Boston for the transaction of criminal business within the county of Suffolk,” charging that the defendant on a certain day, “ and on divers other days and times between that day and the day of making this complaint,” at Boston, did keep and maintain a tenement “ then and on said other days and times there resorted to for illegal gaming, and then and on said other days and times there by him used for illegal gaming,” is sufficient.</p> <p>On a complaint for keeping and maintaining a tenement for illegal gaming, it is a question of fact for the jury whether the defendant did or did not keep the tenement during a substantial portion of the time alleged, and whether, if kept by him, it was resorted to for illegal gaming, and whether “ policy ” is a form of illegal gaming.</p> <p>At the trial of a complaint for keeping and maintaining a tenement for illegal gaming, the judge instructed the jury that the Commonwealth must prove, beyond a reasonable doubt, all the essential allegations of the complaint; that they must be satisfied that, during some substantial portion of the time alleged, the defendant kept the tenement in question, and that during such period it was with his consent resorted to and used for illegal gaming; that it was not necessary to prove that the defendant was the owner of the premises, or the one who usually kept them, but that it was sufficient if, for a substantial portion of the time, he had and exercised sole charge, control, and management thereof while they were so resorted to and' used; and that it must be proved, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant personally kept and maintained the tenement in question during some substantial portion of the time specified for the purpose of its being resorted to and used for illegal gaming, defining illegal gaming substantially as requested by the defendant. Held, that the defendant had no ground of exception.</p> <p>One who goes to a house alleged to be kept and maintained for purposes of illegal gaming, and engages in such gaming himself for the express purpose of appearing as a witness for the government against the proprietor, is not an accomplice.</p>

Relies on Commonwealth v. Clancy · Commonwealth v. Clark · Commonwealth v. Hoar

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1892-01-06

How this case has been cited

Cited by 9 later decisions (1 by the Supreme Court) — most recently December 2008

8 state decisions

30189219001910192019301940195019601970198019902000decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Morton, J.

¶1Without considering the requests of the defendant successively, we think it enough to say that we discover no error in the instructions as given, nor in the refusal to give such requests or make such rulings as were desired. The form of the complaint was sufficient. The court to which the complaint was addressed was sufficiently described. Commonwealth v. Hoar, 121 Mass. 375. Commonwealth v. Clancy, 154 Mass. 128. The time and place were sufficiently set out, and -it was not necessary to describe the kind of illegal gaming that was carried on. Commonwealth v. Logan, 12 Gray, 136. Commonwealth v. Langley, 14 Gray, 21. Commonwealth v. Edds, 14 Gray, 406. The allegation that the tenement was resorted to for illegal gaming was sufficient. It was not necessary to aver that it was used as a common gaming-house for the purpose of gaming for money, and that idle and dissolute persons resorted to it for that purpose. Commonwealth v. Goulding, 135 Mass. 552. Commonwealth v. Clark, 145 Mass. 251.

¶2, It was a question of fact for the jury whether the defendant did or did not keep the tenement during a substantial portion of *291the time alleged, and whether, if kept by him, it was resorted to for illegal gaming while he kept it, and whether “ policy ” was a form of illegal gaming. The instructions requested by the defendant as to the burden of proof, and what it was necessary for the Commonwealth to prove in order to convict the defendant, and as to what constituted illegal gaming, were given substantially as requested by him, with the exception of the third request, which was properly refused in the form in which it was presented. It is enough to say of this» request, that it asked the court to rule entirely as matter of law upon what, to some extent at least, were questions of fact for the jury. The court rightly refused to rule as matter of law that officer O’Brien was an accomplice. Commonwealth, v. Willard, 22 Pick. 476. Commonwealth v. Downing, 4 Gray, 29. It follows that the other rulings requested, which were based on the assumption that O’Brien was as matter of law an accomplice, were also rightly refused.

¶3 Exceptions overruled.

/155/mass/287 · .json · Public domain