Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

155 Mass. 378

Blount v. Kimpton

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court

Decided January 8, 1892

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court · decided 1892-01-08

<p>Evidence — Attorney and Client — Privileged Communication — Bill of Exceptions.</p> <p>Confidential communications made by a client to his attorney, for the purpose of obtaining his advice and assistance in reference to the subject matter thereof, cannot, although made in the presence and hearing of a third person, be disclosed by the attorney without the consent of the client.</p> <p>Where a bill of exceptions alleged by a defendant stated that at the trial of the case in a lower court the plaintiff produced as a witness his counsel; who testifled to "transactions” between the parties, it was held that it could not be assumed in favor of the excepting party to mean that the counsel testified to conversations between himself and client.</p>

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

““They [defendants] contend that if they are made in the presence and hearing of a third person, that removes the privilege, and makes the testimony of the attorney concerning them admissible. But, as between the client and attorney, they are still confidential, though made in the presence or hearing of a third person. The only effect of that is that they are less confidential in fact, and that such third party may testify to them. It does not qualify the attorney as a witness.””

quoted by 1 later decision, including Hartness v. Brown

Relies on Montgomery v. Pickering

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1892-01-08

How this case has been cited

Cited by 12 later decisions — most recently June 1991

5 federal appellate · 7 state decisions

5018921900191019201930194019501960197019801990decided

Later decisions citing this case, by decade. The current decade is in progress, and our corpus holds fewer opinions from the most recent years, so the latest bars are undercounted — not a real decline.

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

Morton, J.

¶1The defendants do not question the well settled rule that confidential communications made by a client to an attorney for the purpose of obtaining his advice and assistance in reference to the matter which is the subject of them cannot be disclosed by the attorney without the consent of the client. Foster v. Hall, 12 Pick. 89. They contend that, if they are made in the presence and hearing of a third person, that removes the privilege, and makes the testimony of the attorney concerning them admissible. But as between the client and attorney they are still confidential, though made in the presence or hearing of a third party. The only effect of that is that they are less confidential in fact, and that such third party may testify to them. It does not qualify the attorney as a witness. Hoy v. Morris, 13 Gray, 519.

¶2The defendants also urge that the privilege has been waived by the plaintiff, for the reason, as they contend, that in the lower court the plaintiff called the attorney as a witness, and interrogated him as to the conversation between the attorney and himself, when the former was acting as counsel for him, in reference to the transaction now in suit. It is possible that the fact may have been as the defendants assert. It is possible also that the attorney may not have testified or not have been interrogated by the plaintiff as to the conversations. The fact that he testified to other things would constitute no waiver of the privilege as to the conversations. Montgomery v. Pickering, 116 Mass. 227. The exceptions do not state that he testified to the conversations, but to the “ above mentioned transactions.” That may mean, and naturally would mean, that he testified to what was done, not to what was said. We cannot assume, in favor of the defendants, who are the excepting party and have the burden, that the fact was as they contend. It is unnecessary to consider, therefore, whether the privilege was or was not waived.

¶3 Exceptions overruled.

/155/mass/378 · .json · Public domain