Public-domain · open source
OpenJurist

156 F.2d 436

Docket No. 11160.

Lurie v. Commissioner

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals

Decided June 27, 1946.

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals · decided 1946-06-27

Cited by 10 later decisions — most recently July 1968

3 federal appellate ·

2 counsel of record

Key passage — most relied on by later courts

“SEO. 1232. BONDS AND OTHER EVIDENCES OF INDEBTEDNESS. (a) Generad Rote. — For purposes of this subtitle, in tbe case of bonds, debentures, notes, or certificates or other evidences of indebtedness, which are capital assets in the hands of the taxpayer, and which are issued by any corporation, or government or political subdivision thereof— (1) Retirement. — Amounts received by the holder on retirement of such bonds or other evidences of indebtedness shall be considered as amounts received in exchange therefor (except that, in the ease of bonds or other .evidences of indebtedness issued before January 1, 1955,.this paragraph shall apply only to those issued with interest coupons or in registered form, or to those in such form on March 1,1954).”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Driscoll v. Commissioner

“must be in registered form at the time of its retirement, but it need not be in registered form at the time of its issuance.”

quoted by 1 later decision, including Driscoll v. Commissioner

Relies on Dobson v. Commissioner · Commissioner v. Wilcox · Lurie v. Commissioner

Good law ✅— No negative treatment on recordhow we know

Decided 1946-06-27

View the full empirical analysis of this case →

¶1Oscar Samuels and Tevis Jacobs, both of San Francisco, Cal., for petitioner.

¶2Sewall Key, Acting Asst. Atty. Gen., Robert N. Anderson, Louise Foster and Eugene E. Beyer, Sp. Assts. to the Atty. Gen., all of Washington, D. C., for respondent.

¶3Before GARRECHT, MATHEWS and ORR, Circuit Judges.

¶4MATHEWS, Circuit Judge.

¶5Notes issued by Hilton Hotel Company, a corporation, in 1938 were acquired by petitioner, Babette G. Lurie, in 1938 and 1939 and were held by her until their retirement. The notes were registered in 1940. They were retired in 1941, more than 24 months after their acquisition by petitioner and less than 18 months after their registration. From their retirement a gain resulted. Petitioner, in computing her net income for 1941, took into account only 50% of the gain so resulting. Respondent, the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, held that 100% thereof should have been taken into account. He accordingly determined a deficiency in respect of petitioner’s income tax for 1941. The Tax Court sustained his determination.1 Its decision is here for review. The question is: What percent*437age of the gain resulting from the retirement of the notes should have been taken into account in computing petitioner’s net income ?

¶6Subsections (b) and (f) of § 117 of the Revenue Act of 1938, 26 U.S.C.A. Int.Rev. Acts, pp. 1062, 1063, provide:

¶7“(b) Percentage taken into account.— In the case of a taxpayer, other than a corporation, only the following percentages of the gain or loss recognized upon the sale or exchange of a capital asset2 shall be taken into account in computing net income:

¶8“100 per centum if the capital asset has been held for not more than 18 months;

¶9“66% per centum if the capital asset has been held for more than 18 months but not for more than 24 months;

¶10“50 per centum if the capital asset has been held for more than 24 months.”

¶11“(f) Retirement of bonds, fete. — For the purposes of this title [§§ 1-373 of the Act], amounts received by the holder upon the retirement of bonds, debentures, notes, or certificates or other evidences of indebtedness issued by any corporation (including those issued by a government or political subdivision thereof), with interest coupons or in registered form, shall be considered as amounts received in exchange therefor.” Admittedly, the notes here in question were capital assets and were held by petitioner for more than 24 months. They were not coupon notes, but were, at the time of their retirement, in registered form. Hence the amount received by petitioner upon their retirement was an amount received in exchange therefor. Hence only 50% of the gain resulting from their retirement should have been taken into account in computing petitioner’s net income. See subsections (b) and (f), supra.

¶12Respondent contends that, because the notes were not issued in registered form, they did not come within subsection (f). The Tax Court did not so hold, nor is there any basis for such a holding. To come within subsection (f), a note must be issued by a corporation and, unless it is a coupon note, must be in registered form at the time of its retirement, but it need not be in registered form at the time of its issuance.

¶13 The Tax Court held that, because the notes were in registered form for less than 18 months, they did not come within subsection (f). In so holding, the Tax Court read into subsection (f) a provision which it does not contain, namely, that, to come within it, a note must be in registered form for at least 18 months — a provision which only Congress could enact, and which Congress has not enacted. The holding was a clear-cut mistake of law. We can and should correct the mistake.3

¶14Decision reversed.

/156/f2d/436 · .json · Public domain